Find
out how
the world media sees Egypt...
![](../../clock.gif)
FOR
LATEST HEADLINES PLEASE GO TO
THE FRONT PAGE OF
CAIROLIVE.COM
US-Egypt strategic
dialogue launched...
At the same time, Mubarak rejects
foreign influence...
Another Washington Post editorial about Egypt backtracking
on democracy..
No need
for a vice president since there's a prime minister, Mubarak
says...
More criticism
of new press law... A
day without papers... 300 journalists protest
against the new law… Newspapers not publishing on
Sunday rise to 28…
Two blogger
activists released...
The Kefaya corruption
report...
Parliament accepts
aid from Denmark...
A writer tries
to figure out who Egypt's messiah
will be... A blogger
says the thread
connecting
current, politically flamboyant events is “that they all
dramatise the modern political struggle between a repressive state
wielding draconian laws, and citizens seeking the repeal and
reform of such oppressive ordinances.”
Mubarak
steps in at last minute to change controversial press law,
but many journalists are still concerned…
Some journalists hail...
Human rights groups not
happy... Meanwhile, ruling NDP starts its own paper, claims it
will be objective...
Earlier: Plus, more
reactions…
Earlier: High-level
delegation to meet in DC next week to discuss strategic
US-Egypt ties.
27 more
members of the Muslim Brotherhood arrested…
Earlier story...
Leader
again...
IHT argues that "nowhere... has a new indifference to democracy
[on the past of the Bush administration] been more striking
than in Egypt..."
Detailed legal
explanation of the new judicial law...
More details
on why the judges dont like their new law... Despite everything, new
judicial law passes
in parliament...
Rebel priest
leads
Coptic split...
Newsweek
wonders what might happen after
Mubarak. Meanwhile,
the president promises unprecedented
reforms in 2007...
Blogger
Alaa gives his first
post-release interview to Newsweek... Journalists are on trial for exposing
alleged judicial corruption... More
Muslim Brotherhood arrests..
MEDIA
A
day without papers...
300 journalists protest
against the new press law… Newspapers not publishing on
Sunday rise to 28… Western press not very accurate with names:
Reuters calls Masry El-Youm editor Magdy El-Galad -- El-Galal…
and Ahram editor Osama Saraya -- Faraya...
Earlier
story from BBC: some
two dozen newspapers are suspending
publication for a day to protest a new law they say will
prevent them investigating corruption.
Earlier: Independent and opposition papers will not come out on Sunday
to protest press freedom restrictions...
Press confusion... Destour
editor Ibrahim Eissa and others sentenced to jail time for publishing
an article about a lawsuit against the president... Journalists
and rights groups react...
Photo of Eissa
at news conference following verdict...
A
look at "How Egyptians
are getting their news
in 2006"...
Judges Club
still not
happy... Details
about why
the Judges Club doesn't like the new judicial law...
Government sends new judicial bill to parliament without
even consulting the judges... Brotherhood
calls new judiciary law "disappointing..." Plus, UN steps in to urge
Egypt on judicial independence...
Another
critical Washington Post op-ed lambasting the Bush administration
for not doing anything about Egypt's democratic backtracking...
The Guardian's Whitaker continues
to skewer the same...
Earlier:
Alaa Abdel Fattah, the blogger who was arrested during pro-democracy
protests last month "and continued to blog from his
cell," was ordered released...
Meanwhile, two other blogger
activists still
in jail...
An eloquent requiem
for longtime lawyer and activist Ahmed Nabil El-Hilali...
Alaa
al-Aswani, the author and activist who wrote The Yacoubian
Building, a best-selling novel about corruption, told AFP he had
been barred
from attending the Cairo premiere of the book's film version
because of his politics... Plus, photo
of stars Youssra and Nour El-Sherif at the premier.
An in-depth look at the
brotherhood's political prospects...
Hoping
against hope?
A strong
Guardian commentary
reveals the tragic situation of politics today... A brief Telegraph encounter
with Manal of manalaa.net, just before she visits her famous
activist blogger husband Alaa in jail... Alaa provides a couple of interesting
drawings of his
cell..
A
reasonable proposal? A response
to Alterman's Post op-ed... Earlier: A highly-placed
US academic pens a pragmatic approach
to US-Egypt relations in a Washington Post op-ed... His
conclusions include: "We also need to have our security and
intelligence professionals work with their Egyptian counterparts
to reach common understandings of common threats, especially with
regard to radicalism and violence. Such efforts should
simultaneously seek to reach agreement on the kinds of political
activity that are not threatening to public order... Finally,
the United States needs to continue to press for greater openness
and participation in Egypt. The world is changing, and the old
methods of political control no longer work. The Egyptian
government knows this, and it is seeking to adapt. Its efforts may
be insufficient or ineffective, and it will have to live with the
consequences. Our role should be to encourage and prod. Getting
into a public spitting match with the Egyptian government would
have precisely the opposite effect." Meanwhile, Newsweek
suggests Mubarak
knows that Bush is too busy
to worry about democratization in Egypt... Baltimore Sun columnist
says "U.S. silence on Egypt betrays
democracy activists..." Earlier:
Very close US House
no-vote to trim
aid to Egypt... More from AFP...
Striking a
balance...
UPI
reports on Muslim Brotherhood leader Mahdi Akef calling
for a refendum on Camp David... Earlier, Akef said tourists
could drink alcohol inside their hotels and people should decide
for themselves whether to accept bank interest... Meanwhile,
at least 100
of the group's members were arrested at a huge protest...
Fighting
for Nour...
Over 100
Egyptian MPs have signed an appeal asking President Hosni Mubarak
to order the release of Ayman Nour. Plus, nine NDPers
almost signed...
Office
politics... Released young activist promptly gets fired
from his job at a multinational. Arabist has the details...
Former NDP leader Osama Ghazali Harb announces plans
to found new Freedom and Justice party...
A scholarly
Carnegie look at the Gamal issue... Plus, a cartoon blogger quips
about Gamal and his fiance at Davos Sharm...
Blogger
Baheyya profiles recently deceased 70s student leader
Ahmed Abdalla... Plus,
a brief look at the emerging
activism of groups like shayfencom... and
a new phenomenon -- activists' online
radio stations...
Judges still haven't seen
the draft of a new judiciary law set to be discussed in special
Wednesday cabinet session...
Storm in a teacup?
A Gulf News columnist
tries to figure out why Washington is acting
the way it is...
Plus,
the US-based International Republican Institute
has been told to stop
its activities in Egypt, after the director made some negative
comments about the reform process in the press... Meanwhile,
US
ambassador provides typically
ambiguous comments on reform at an AmCham event... Plus,
US State Department comments
on treatment of judge-supporting detainee Mohamed El-Sharqawy...
Earlier: the
US embassy in Cairo denied
its ambassador had made comments about Washington's aid that had
Egyptian MPs up in arms... Earlier, minor parliamentary skirmishes
on Egypt-US ties... Meanwhile, a U.S. House committee backs full aid to Egypt...
Fire at Ayman
Nour's headquarters...
Power politics...
More brotherhood arrests...
Nazif tries to explain his get rid of the brotherhood from
parliament ideas...
More here...
Plus, a look at the brotherhood's economic
leanings... Earlier: 33 brotherhood
arrests...
Plus, brotherhood withdraws
from commerce chamber elections... after media team arrested
while covering...
Silence...
No government response to BBC reporters' attack complaint...
Anger
in London over 2 BBC reporters who were assaulted after a demo...
Turning the tide?
The
government's own human rights organization said Egyptian police
and security forces should reassess
"excessively cruel security measures" used against
protesters in recent demonstrations in Cairo. Meanwhile, Time recounts young activists arrests, and
predicts they still wont be silenced...
and the Telegraph is impressed
about Ahdaf Soueif joining
a demonstration...
Third
way?
The Globe and Mail asks why the
US doesn't find "a middle
ground between hurling Egypt into the void and standing
quietly by as Mr. Mubarak stomps on his democratic
opponents." Mona El-Tahawy migrates to Maktoob, penning a scathing
op-ed about recent events... Meanwhile, an anonymous
blogger pens
an angry SOS in CS Monitor... A prominent Guardian commentator echoes
the call.. Another blogger posts about his guilt over not
doing anything about police brutality... A translation
of Destour's interview with a top security officer... Meanwhile,
judge-supporting detainee
examined
for torture, but still not treated...
Media
coverage of judge-supporting detainees steps up... AP does a bigger
story on Alaa blogging from jail... They also select some choice quotes...
Jailed activists on hunger strike
until another detainee is examined... Baheyya urges support
for all prisoners of conscience, regardless of political
affiliation... Kefaya steps
up the game with a parliamentary reform plan... And
an interesting Media
Monitors Network column suggests that it's going to be a long
hot summer... Earlier,
Ahdaf Soueif
wrote in the Guardian:
"Practically every sector of Egyptian society now finds
itself in conflict with a regime that aligns its interests with
those of a very narrow business elite and uses the security
apparatus to stifle dissent..."
The
judges...
At least 300
Egyptian judges stood in silence outside the high court on
Thursday in protest against what they say is state interference in
the judiciary... BBC's version includes a photo... AFP says 500...
Interesting
first hand account of a downtown demo in support of the judges, by
the Arabist... Random
quotes, courtesy of blogger Sandmonkey... Plus,
AUC students sit
in for the judges... as do people around the world...VOA reports that
"it was only afterward,
when most of the news media had left, that several protesters were
grabbed from the streets, beaten and reportedly detained by
police.." Major
AP
and AFP
coverage of arrests, roughing up, and
possible torture... Reporters
without borders issues a statement...
An article asks if the
regime is becoming more brutal because it is
convinced the US
wont do anything?
Meanwhile, 41
student protestors (from an earlier demonstration) are released...
NY Sun asks if the age of protest is over?
(The whole article is registration only, but the free intro is
still interesting...). Egyptian ambassador to
Canada defends
the security
apparatus.... Plus, a
blogger's opinion...
Press under fire...
Now journalists
-- including the prominent Wael El-Ibrashi of Sowt El-Umma and
Dream TV -- are being taken to court for publishing names of
judges who allegedly rigged elections... Meanwhile, other
journalists detained and harrassed while covering a rural
protest...
Lots
of different talking heads in this dispatch
on the current political situation... Some saw Thursday as a potential
turning point...
UPI notes that no
clashes occured this time... An interesting map showing
where different protests were taking place worldwide... AUC
students support
one of their jailed, judge-supporting colleagues with t-shirts...
An in-depth
PBS piece on blogging and activism... And the US's message
to the opposition....
Interesting
quote: "Unfortunately we don't have much zeal
for democracy and participation in the Arab world,"
director of Egypt's Al-Ahram Center for Political and Strategic
Studies Abdel Monem Said Aly said. "No one really is willing
to die for democracy. And other countries created that. There are
no Mandelas here in our societies. But we have people who are
willing to die because they don't like tourism for instance."
No
hurry? Washington
Post editorial hits hard...
Foreign
minister trying to put a positive
spin on slow reform... Analysts respond
to government's claim that reform needs to be slow so as
not to cause chaos... "Real stability comes from allowing
people to peacefully participate in a country's
policymaking."" says one... The US is critical
as well: "These (actions) strike me as not only wrong actions
but mistakes, like beating people up and the heavy-handed security
reaction to these things... The reason I say that is (because) I
think that they conflict with the government's own desires and
interests and where they (government) want Egypt to go," he
added, citing government plans for reform. Earlier, Nazif
said Egypt is not
in a hurry when it comes to political
reform... The
prime minister's delves into politics and economics are
featured in full
here... Mubarak also denies
turning his back on reform...
Brotherhood upset
about Nazif's comments... More brotherhood commentary...
At the forum...
Lots
of economic news emerging from the Davos economic summit
in Sharm El-Sheikh:
The flip side of
Sharm
Davos optimism
-- how the brain drain chokes... Sawiris talks politics
on the sidelines of Davos Sharm -- how he refuses to join the NDP
or become a minister, and wants to start a liberal business-driven
party... Whimsical
coverage of a journalist's trip to Davos Sharm... Plus, more musings,
along with a lot of positive economic forecasts, from Business
Week...
Photo: Gamal
and fiance
make an appearance at Davos Sharm... Knight Ridder gushes...
"The
chairman of Egypt's largest offshore call centre company said on
Sunday his company was growing
at 50 percent a year and that in this sector Egypt could become to
Europe what India is to the United States..." Meanwhile,
Egypt announced that it would delay
the sale of state assets because of a decline in the nation's
benchmark index this year... Earlier,
Egyptian president Hosni Mubarak's opening speech gets
play as tough anti-US tome: AP
and Knight
Ridder surprised at the harsh tone. Questions about
why Iran, Syria and Hamas were not invited...
A commentator tries to make the link
between economic and political reform... The forum began
on Saturday... AP reports on the tense
atmosphere surrounding the event... Egypt urging more
Arab economic integration on the summit's eve...
Just another
Thursday?
312
people were arrested on Thursday during demos in solidarity
with independence- seeking judges... Harsh treatment of
protestors results in major Congressional USAID tensions...
A commentator says maybe the judges shouldn't
be treated as heroes...
Kansas City Star asks
Nazif some tough questions.... Disciplinary panel rules
-- Mekky cleared, Bastawisi warned... Meanwhile, it's
another day of downtown clashes with judge-supporting
demonstrators... First on the scene reports emerging from Reuters
say hundreds of Muslim Brotherhood supporters arrested,
including Essam El-Erian... A good primer
on what's going on with the judges, courtesy of Arabist... One of
the judges -- Hisham Bastawisi -- has a heart
attack on the eve of the hearings... Bastawisi's
struggle highlighted
by Philadelphia paper.. New York Times sets the scene for today's two
courtroom showdowns... A few interesting quotes
on page 2 of this New York Sun scene-setter... Speculations
about plans and mishaps... Activists plan to defy
demo crackdown... More here..
Another
Guardian commentary on blogger Alaa... 50
Shiben El-Kom brotherhood demonstrators arrested for supporting
the judges...
Endless debate...
Former ambassador
Welch defends
Egypt in congressional aid cut showdown... The $2
billion USAID quagmire.
Earlier Washington Post editorial on same...
Plus, the
debate
in Washington over the effectiveness of US military assistance...
What
was Gamal Mubarak doing at the White House:
Guardian wonders
why Bush was being friendly... A look at the different speculation
surrounding the visit last Friday, just one day after the globally
broadcast crushing of judicial independence supporters by police.
Not many details so far, although the Washington Post has the most comprehensive
coverage, including lots of quotes from Ambassador
to Washington Nabil Fahmi... Pravda also tries...
Gamal was in Washington on private business, AP says,
but also met wiith Bush, Cheney and an NSA big... Plus,
from UPI, the brotherhood's latest
thinking on Gamal, and astonishment
at the US reaction to the Nour case..
PLUS: Complete
coverage in Arabic...
LATEST
JUDGES PROTESTS COVERAGE:
Police announce a zero-tolerance
stance regarding protests at Thursday's judicial hearing...
Meanwhile, the EU has criticised
Egypt for the way it deals with protests and dissent. CS
Monitor explains why blogger Alaa is important,
and how other bloggers are helping
him... A writer says the emergency law has turned Egyptians into
people who dont want to get into trouble...
Daily Star suggests that the judges issue is also impeding
economic reform... Guardian hits hard
on Mubarak's non-commitment... plus a commentary on how not
to handle the political vacuum... Time finds some Egyptian heroes...Daily
Star covers the demo in London in support of the judges... CNN does a quick video
feature on blogger Alaa's arrest...
Remember
Ayman Nour? His appeal is Thursday. One analyst suggests that
"if Nour had five years to develop a political
message, he'd be much more popular than he is now."
What
now?
The
ramifications of last Thursday's troubling series of events -- the
massive show of police force preventing judges and lawyers from
attending a disciplinary meeting for two of their judicial
colleagues who said elections were rigged, and the unnecessarily harsh treatment of peaceful protestors
by security forces
--
are only just beginning to appear.... For the latest
updates in Arabic, check zahma.com...
FIRST-HAND:
Jarring account in Time...
Knight Ridder's blow-by-blow...
Plus, striking
first
hand accounts on the Arabist, and detailed reports from AP,
Reuters
and AFP...
Where there really 237
arrests? Journalists
and demonstrators prevented
from gathering...
Plus, a detailed blogger's description
of the protest... Meanwhile, a police truck crashes
on its way to the scene, killing 7 and injuring many
others...
US REACTS:
The State Department's statement includes terms like
"particularly troubling," "we are deeply concerned,"
and "we will be following up with the Egyptian government
regarding our concerns"... AP calls the US reaction soft...
Reuters sees it in a much harsher
light... Here's the
full text of the State Dept. statement....
Meanwhile, the government
defends
the massive security presence at the court...
COMMENTARIES:
Analyst and activist Mohamed El-Sayed Said tells
FT that civil society can not really counter
such a gigantic police machine... This blogger's post
says government harshness may be par for the course, but it may
also have longer term ramifications.. Baheyya argues that the
regime miscalculated
both the judges, and the public's reaction to government
brutality. She also weighs in on where
the judges may be heading, and how much public support they're
getting... ... Rami Khouri thinks the judges may get a lot
more popular support, and in the process influence the rest of the
Arab world as well... VOA tries to link the whole thing to the inheritance
debate, and Gamal Mubarak says reform is really still
on the agenda...
Meanwhile,
the judges themselves speak
up in the Guardian: "There have been almost 50 arrests on
the charge of 'supporting the judges', even though this
is not a crime in Egyptian law. These arrests took place under
emergency laws despite the government's insistence that it would
only use them in cases of drug-dealing or terrorism. These young
men and women have not committed any crime other than supporting
our campaign for an independent judiciary."
One of the
most famous of the detainees, blogger Alaa, blogs from prison...
Meanwhile, blogger Alb Sayed posts a poignant
comment about the price of freedom... Limited protests
at Egyptian embassies and consulates in the US asking for
detainees release... This
report counts 100
protest arrests in past weeks... A roundup
of how the blog scene is reacting to activist and blogger Alaa's
arrest... Global Voices reports on the well-known
Google technique being used to give the campaign more
prominence...
Thursday's hearing
was the second
stage in a controversial disciplinary process... CS Monitor tries to
go in-depth:
"The authorities are afraid to make concessions to the
judges... because officials are worried that this will
just empower other reformist groups. 'The government doesn't
want to look like it's lost,' says Chief Justice Tarek
el-Tawil, 'even though if it accepts our demands it'll be
very popular. But the government doesn't want to look like it's
conceded. Then all the other political groups will make a move and
it could lose control.'" Plus, other judges may go on
strike if disciplinary committee removes their colleagues from
the bench...
Serious situation...
Number
of activists recently under arrest goes up to at least 48...
Their detention to last for at least 15
days... One of the charges includes insulting
the president. The incarcerated group includes prominent blogger Alaa...
Read more about it here,
and on Global
Voices...)
Albright encourages unwavering
US support for democracy... An American paper tries
to go deeper
into the judges versus the government debate... Washington
Post harsh
on emergency law extension... US calls it a real disappointment...
Boston Globe hits hard...
What the emergency law entails...
Emergency law
extended for two
years... Over a hundred parliamentarians disagreed...
Knight Ridder calls it a setback
to the Bush administration... AP says government appears to be lashing
out in all directions... Opposition slams
decision... Meanwhile, Newsweek is not
optimistic about reform, and blogger Baheyya comments on
where
the current chaos may be taking Egypt...
Military matters still
off
limits for a generally freer press...
23 Muslim brotherhood
activists rounded
up... CBS column predicts greater regime-brotherhood
cooperation
against hardline Islamists... Reuters predicts the rise
of Gamal...Thoughtful Maria Golia Daily Star column on the
emergency law's corrosive
effect on society... A scathing
comment by the Guardian's Brian Whitaker.. Meanwhile, 18
Muslim Brotherhood activists arrested...
Tense
downtown: NY
Times and
Washington
Post weigh in on the government's
harsh response to demos in
support of the judges... Ayman Nour's lawyer seems to have disappeared
during the protests... Earlier: Police seal
off court at center of
judges vs government dispute...
downtown traffic stalls as a result.. Protesters
beaten and arrested... Rights activists cry foul...
Worried
about satellites...
Jazeera Cairo office chief detained
by police for broadcasting false news... Committee to Protect
Journalists statement
on the arrest...
Independent: Mubarak is
between
repression & reform
Judge hospitalized
after protest... Police have broken
up a pro-reform protest at the Judges' Syndicate,
beating a senior judge & detaining 15 protesters...
No spring
this year? Kifaya struggling
for support a year later...
Ahram analyst says backlash
against reform has already begun. Meanwhile, Ayman Nour to be transferred
to Qasr El-Aini hospital, and ex-Wafd chief Gomaa
free on bail...
A
critical hint? "Prime
Minister Ahmed Nazif says the verdict
is still out
on official claims that the recent attacks on churches in
Alexandria were committed by a mentally unstable man... "During
investigations, we must not be hasty. I would rather not
say this man is crazy or not, because hastiness detracts from
credibility and could lead to a more serious crisis," Nazif
told Al-Ahram..."
Not yet?
President Hosni Mubarak gave a strong hint
he would extend emergency laws when they expire in June,
saying a legislative vacuum before the passing of new
anti-terrorism laws would be a “serious danger”.
A group
of 50 judges is holding a sit-in
protest at the judges' association in central Cairo...
Blogger
Baheyya weighs
in on the judges debate...
More on the
judges from VOA,
BBC...
The
government has sent two prominent judges to a disciplinary
board for possible expulsion from the judiciary, raising the
stakes in a conflict between the government and judges seeking
judicial independence..
Meanwhile,
the government said it had broken up a group of at least 22
militant Islamists planning bomb attacks on tourist
targets, a gas pipeline near Cairo and Muslim and Christian
religious leaders...
POLITICS
FT tries its
hand at the judges
vs goverment dispute...
Activists
say the state fabricates
evidence to support criminal charges against members of the opposition...
Meanwhile, authorities
have stopped jailed opposition leader Ayman Nour from sending
articles to his newspaper... Plus, about 900
members of the militant group Gamaa Islamiya released from jail...
Meanwhile, the Hizb u Tahrir Brtions speak
up about their negative experiences in the Egyptian
penal
system...
Bush
chooses not
to
weigh in on the Gamal Mubarak question...
"When
an Egyptian asked him at a forum in Washington last week whether
he would support Gamal Mubarak if he succeeded his father, Hosni
Mubarak, as president of Egypt, Bush declined to answer: "That's
a question-I-don't-answer question,"
he said. There's more about this, and Bush's comments on last
year's elections, on
the full White House transcript
of the event, which includes the following exchange:
"Q
Mr. President, I'm from the Public International Law and Policy
Group. I'm also from Egypt and I aspire to one day go back there
and join Egyptian politics. So my question is --"
THE PRESIDENT: Go for President. (Laughter.)
Q I'm working on it, I'm working on it -- in 2017,
everyone. (Laughter.) But my question is, would you support the
regime of Gamal Mubarak if he takes over after President Mubarak?
THE PRESIDENT: That's a leading question. (Laughter.)
That's a question I don't answer question. (Laughter.) I support a
country which does not fear political movements, but is willing to
compete with political movements. That's the kind of country I
support."
Meanwhile,
in
a rare interview on state television, Gamal Mubarak
insisted he had no
plans to run in the next
presidential election in 2011... More
on the succession issue from the Khaleej Times...
POLITICS
Activists said the
last-minute cancellation of a meeting between representatives of
Human Rights Watch and the Cairo-based Judges' Club exposed
the judiciary's lack of independence from the authorities...
No intervention:
Government manages to scuttle
Human Rights Watch attempt to meet angry judges... More
from Reuters.
Some Arabic reporting suggests
clear messages are being sent...
Unlikely
ally? Condi defends
Washington's large aid program to Egypt against criticisms that
Cairo has not made enough progress in democratic reforms.
UN report sees
most political parties in total disarray...
Wafd
in flames: Court
orders 45
days detention for ousted
Wafd party chairman Noman
Gomaa.
Sad
state: KR explores nasty reactions
to editor Osama El-Ghazali Harb's ruling party
resignation...
Another
analysis of the Muslim Brotherhood's parliamentary performance so
far...
Gomaa and 14 of his supporters
have
been jailed...
The
once legendary party continues to sink, as Gomaa
stormed the party's offices on Saturday, wreaking havoc
for hours before being arrested. "Witnesses and the official
MENA news agency said Gomaa himself fired shots at Wafd
journalists." Coverage from Reuters,
AFP,
AP.
Plus, a blogger's
detailed pictorial
account.
Plus, 10 more
brotherhood members arrested.
Nice column on the
need
for greater enforcement of laws...
Mixed up
world! AP wonders whether Amr Khaled will become less popular
because he's advocating co-existence
instead of clash...
A brief look
at where
the Egyptian press is now... Global newspaper body calls on President Hosni Mubarak to take
action to prevent journalists being jailed...
Knight Ridder evaluates
the Muslim Brotherhood's parliamentary
performance...
All
over TV: Authorities
have agreed to lift
immunity from the owner of the Al Salam 98 ferry. (Of
course, he might already be out of the country...) There's a lot
more about this and the delayed decision to lift former Ahram boss
Ibrahim Nafie's immunity in
Arabic on zahma.com.
Blogger Baheyya chronicles
Friday's silent demonstration by Egypt's judges... Here's AP's report
as well.
Activists condemn journalist's libel
conviction, as well as
the just announced sunken ferry compensation
sums...
A
matter of planning... Washington Post outlines the ways in which the scene
has been set for Gamal Mubarak's succession...
The article's key quote seems to be from Misry El-Youm CEO Hisham
Kassem: ""I don't think Gamal can make
it," said Kassem, the newspaper editor. "His group calls
itself reformist, but it is based on simple nepotism, with Gamal
at the center. When the father goes, this group could quickly lose
altitude. Everyone will be yelling, 'Mayday, Mayday.' Not a happy
situation."
Will
this move change anything: "Osama
El Ghazali Harb, a member of the National Democratic Party’s
influential policy committee, said he was quitting
after the committee — led by by President Hosni Mubarak’s son,
Gamal — failed to adopt suggestions he and other pro-reform
members havemade." Plus, much
more coverage in Arabic from Masry El-Youm on zahma.com...
Tough
position: Presidential
adviser Osama El-Baz tells Reuters that Hosni Mubarak would
step
down if he thought there was anyone out there who
could replace him... El-Baz also claims that Mubarak is not
considering a Gamal sucession plan...
Now is the
time to register
to vote... even though -- much to the opposition's
dismay -- nobody really
knows about it...
Chicago paper wonders
whether Muslim Brotherhood will evolve...
New
tactics in government's brotherhood crackdown? More...
More
in the aftermath
of another journalist's prison conviction... Earlier:
Another journalist -- this time from Al-Fajr -- is sentenced
to a prison term... Even earlier: Masry
El-Youm journalist off the hook: "Former Egyptian Housing
Minister Mohamed Ibrahim Suleiman
dropped all his lawsuits against the press on
Friday, clearing the way for an end to a confrontation between the
press and the government over prison sentences."
Chicago
Tribune brands
Ayman Nour as a "model of repression"... Meanwhile,
Muslim Brotherhood student activists
arrested... Plus, secular democracy vs.
religious authority: A columnist tackles the brotherhood conondrum...
Have some political
websites been blocked?
No linkage allowed?
Wapo editorial on Ayman Nour, Hosni Mubarak and
congress withholding
aid... Meanwhile, tough words about politics and free
trade at a
terse and tense Egypt-US meeting ...
Mubarak
warns
US not to attack Iran, and also says "Egypt won
over U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice to
its views on democracy in the Arab world." The president
quoted her as saying "it would take a generation for
democracy to take hold.... She was very polite as she was
listening to Egyptian opinions and points of view. She didn't
bring up difficult issues or ask to change anything or to
intervene in political reform, as some people say," he told
newspaper editors.
Harsh quotes from judges and analysts in AP story
on whether the nation's democratic reform process is dead...
In the story, a judge says: "Anyone who talks about real reform becomes an
accused defendant... People are losing any trust in the seriousness of reform talk, and this is really dangerous. I'm
afraid that would lead to violence."... An analyst says: "the
government has been taking one step forward, two steps back"...
The trauma
being faced by Sudanese refugees in Cairo is spotlighted by
the Washington Post... Plus, the Post's detailed
account of latest sectarian clash in an Egyptian village
over a church....
Surprises at
the Sinai bombings trial...
The Condi
visit roundup...
Another
analysis of the Condi trip's democracy support failure
from the Washington Post... Plus, a prominent columnist
sees a democratic process
of some sort going on... Transcript
of interesting Egyptian TV interview
with Condi... Secular politicos complain to Condi about
being marginalized
by Mubarak... More on the visit from AP,
Washington
Post and CS
Monitor ... Plus, the photo
that says it all... Meanwhile,
Ayman Nour asks Condi if US can help Egypt generate nuclear
power...
Earlier:
First
news
about Condi's Cairo meetings emerge... Lively exchanges
about Hamas and Ayman Nour at the Abul-Gheit press
conference... More from IHT...
Plus, how tough
do you think this Washington Post editorial urging the Bush
administration to push Mubarak harder on democratic reform is?
BBC explores religion
and dissent...
A look at the social
programs that have made the Muslim Brotherhood popular... Guardian picks up New Statesman's leaked
memo story
about Britain wanting to dialogue with the Muslim
Brotherhood. Later,
the UK denies...
Here are the New Statesmen links
to the leaked documents... Meanwhile, prominent
brotherhood members going to trial...
Activists call for a Nour retrial...
and appeal...
Judges in complicated
situation... 3 judges
who often criticize President Hosni Mubarak's administration and
who demanded an investigation into accusations of misconduct in
the recent parliamentary elections have been stripped of their
judicial immunity and face interrogation by state security
prosecutors...
The
US has criticised the Egyptian government's decision to postpone
local council elections
for two years, and will raise the matter with Cairo.
Condi
is coming
to town...
LATEST
DANISH
CARTOON CONTROVERSY
Shaaban
song, new forums and other strange
manifestations
of the
cartoon controversy...
A bit of
lunacy with the BBC -- Egyptians debate
the validity of selling the Protocols of Zion in light of the
Danish cartoon controversy... Plus, Adel Hamouda quoted in Time
magazine: "Those
who saw the cartoons did not react, and those who reacted are the
ones who did not see them." His weekly
al-Fagr ran the cartoons many months ago... Meanwhile,
the foreign
minister calls for dialogue
between East and West...
Egypt's consultative council approved the two-year
postponement of municipal polls that had been due within two
months, in a move slammed by the opposition Muslim Brotherhood...
AP says the brotherhood plans to fight
the postponement...
Cutting piece
in NY Times tries to assess anger over ferry sinking and cartoons:
"If the scope of what happened was unusual, it may be the
only thing that was. Pick
a day. Pick a tragedy. Match the government's
response..." Plus, Saudi Arabian
columnist critical
of his country's port authority...
Much more
sinking ferry ramifications coverage in Arabic on zahma.com
The
controversy that just won't quit...
Juan Cole explores
Egypt's motives
for escalating the Danish cartoon crisis... Plus, other related cartoon news:
--Thirty people were injured
during an Egyptian protest over the controversial caricatures of
Prophet Mohamed after police used tear gas to disperse the
rioters...
--Issues
of German magazines Der Speigel and Focus banned
in Egypt because they feature
the cartoons...
--Egyptian
money changers wont take Danish currency
anymore...
--Islamonline
says Egypt football players and fans supported
Danish boycott during African Nations Cup final...
What's
in store
for the Muslim Brotherhood?
Bush backs
bold new Arab democracy initiative that Egypt had previously
rejected. The other major supporters are Qatar and Denmark...
POLITICS
The Post looks
at how Muslim Brotherhood parliamentarians are changing
the assembly.
UPI says the structural
changes President
Hosni Mubarak made in his ruling National Democratic Party signal
that he is grooming his son, Gamal, to succeed him... Gamal has
become the party's deputy secretary general...
Trying
PR... Prime Minister Nazif pens a pleading editorial
in the Washington Times, and tries to talk
tough politics with Newsweek... Meanwhile,
VOA gets some other
people's opinions on the current state of US-Egypt
relations...
Assembly theatrics
First silly
government-brotherhood fight takes place in parliament,
featuring yelling, a walkout, a mass protest, and then, finally,
an apology...
Presidential
son
speaks
AFP covers the interview Gamal Mubarak gave Rose
El-Youssef, where he said he wasn't
interested in running for president.... A little
more on this part of the interview here... Meanwhile,
Gamal also spoke up
about the Muslim Brotherhood's influence...
A little
more on this part here...
In depth Knight Ridder report on police brutality asks
if violence is growing pains of democracy, or intentional
opposition deterrent...
Chicago Tribune says, "With
real elections in
Iraq, Lebanon and the Palestinian territories, Egypt can't
be rewarded for faking it..."
Egypt's future is
a complex
tale, as this astute Economist analysis makes clear... Meanwhile,
mirror images in this brutal
Washington Post editorial... and Saad's stepped-up
rhetoric in the Globe and Mail...
Scores of activists
have condemned the systematic marginalisation
of women in politics, particularly during last month's
parliamentary elections...
Wafd
stab at democracy?
Reuters reports:
"Egypt's oldest
political party on Wednesday kicked
out its leader after his poor showing in last
September's presidential election, but party officials said that
Noman Gomaa refused to step down...
DOMESTIC POLITICS
What's a weekend without
politics?
AP reports that "the
court that sentenced a top opposition leader to five years in
prison last month issued a report
saying Ayman Nour was convicted because of the
"danger" posed by the defendants' forgery techniques...."
"More than 450 Muslim Brotherhood activists arrested during parliamentary
elections have been freed, a spokesman for the Islamist group
says. But more than 300 members remain behind bars..."
A look at the
Muslim Brotherhood-Zawahiri dispute...
Sadat's nephew Talaat, an MP, calls for a boycott
of all mail coming from Israel in protest against a stamp deemed
offensive to Islam...
Government-sponsored
National Council for Human Rights called for an investigation
into killings during parliamentary elections....
Rights groups are outraged
about the judiciary's decision to dismiss cases of sexual assault
against female activists and journalists during the 25 May
referendum...
Still
analyzing the makeup
Chinese media
looks at new cabinet's economic dreams...
Photo of first
veiled minister. Earth sciences
expert
is the country's new minister for higher education and
scientific research... The accompanying governors' reshuffle
brings first Copt... Earlier, AP does a cabinet
census and discovers the following:
the "new Cabinet retained major personalities of the previous
government, while adding two more pro-American business figures
and installing Egypt's first minister to wear a headscarf, a sign
of Islamic piety in Egypt." The latter was a nod to the
Muslim Brotherhood's supporters, the news agency suggested... Minor/major re-shuffle:
New cabinet details...
More from FT...
Reuters is detailed
about the cabinet's new businessmen...
Beginnings of alcohol
ban talk in parliament...
Columnist
really irked
by Egypt's tepid reform process and the US's wishy-washy reaction
to it...
Let the fallout begin...
Nour's
Ghad party distances
itself from foreign support... Post editorial
demands
US take action on Ayman Nour case... Most interesting paragraph:
"How could Mr. Bush show that Mr. Mubarak is wrong? A first
step would be to suspend all discussions between his
administration and Egypt over a free-trade agreement. Egypt's
business community and the pro-capitalist civilian ministers in
Mr. Mubarak's government regard such an agreement as one of their
top priorities. Many of them privately deplore the persecution of
Mr. Nour but believe it does not affect their interests. They
should be made to understand that it will not be possible for
Egypt to expand U.S. trade and investment as long as Mr. Mubarak
is blocking political reforms." (Earlier, leading
government opponent Ayman Nour convicted
of forging petition signatures... Gets five years jail time... Somewhat
overly dramatic
New York Times piece... LA Times takes a better shot...
And the White House urges his release: "The
conviction of Mr. Nour, the runner-up in Egypt's 2005 presidential
elections, calls into question Egypt's commitment to democracy,
freedom, and the rule of law..."
Coincidences?
Piece on security forces intervention
in politics and media by prominent Al-Ahram columnist Hala Mustafa
appears in Washington Post... She is subsequently trashed by Rose
El-Youssef. Nearly simultaneously, a harsh Mona El-Tahawy column
appears in IHT. It subsequently catalyzes a security services
reprimand...
Full
coverage in Arabic on zahma.com
RAW NEWS
ROUNDUP...
President Hosni Mubarak
asks Prime Minister Ahmed Nazif to form a new cabinet... Who
will be in it? So far, Shazli's out, and so is Ibrahim Soleiman.
"There is
no going back"
President Hosni
Mubarak tells parliament that reforms will continue...
He also asks parliamentarians to "reach
out" to the people...Meanwhile, "Egypt's judges
underlined their status as a driving force for change &
democracy by re-electing their outspoken leader, blasting the
regime over election abuses & pressing
it for more independence"...
Election
analysis:
In MERIP, Issandr
El Amrani pens a very interesting roundup of the just-completed
elections and their impact on the overall political scene. One of
the conclusions
at the end astutely notes that, "The travails of Ayman Nour
throughout 2005 have sent a chilling message to would-be liberal
leaders that the regime will not tolerate the emergence of a
populist-liberal alternative; however, a personality of greater
stature than Nour’s could yet emerge from the debris of the
legal opposition." Plus, SF Chronicle laments
death of liberal
politics...
Thoughtful assembly?
Ambassador Nabil Fahmy talks to US press about
election: "It is an evolution,
not a revolution," he says... Some not
happy with token
minorities being appointed to parliament...The Islamists,
meanwhile, are taking it step
by step... Muslim Brotherhood leader Akef's views on the
Holocaust getting the same kind of play
as Ahmednijade... They also help the anti-Mubarak Kefaya
movement assess
their perfromance in 2005.. Reuters covers their latest demo.
In the
Guardian, novelist Ahdaf Soueif recounts
a long hot summer of protests and changing politics in Cairo...
Ayman Nour's condition a little
bit better...Nour's wife provides a few more details on his condition...(Earlier
story: Nour taken to prison hospital
after his health deteriorated on 8th day of hunger strike in
protest at detainment on forgery charges...)
The President appoints
women and Copts to the assembly...TMuslim Brotherhood leader
Mahdi Akef calls Israel a "cancer"...
Earlier, Time took an inside
look at the Muslim Brotherhood's nerve
center...
A brief look at the new parliament's first
day... Mubarak
wants elections' "negative
aspects answered strongly so that they will not be repeated."
The rest of the speech hailed
the elections as a landmark event...
Newly
elected Islamist members of parliament are open to dialogue
with members of the US
Congress without involving the Cairo government. Meanwhile, the
group's leader Mohammed Mehdi Akef said the brotherhood does
not recognise Israel... His plan: "We will not
combat Israel using its own means, we will do it our way. If 70
million Egyptians reach a high level of education and wealth,
Israel will be powerless and will not be able to do
anything."
Final
parliamentary tally: 26
percent overall turnout.... Ruling
NDP gets 72
percent -- or 311-- of the 432 seats... 112 seats went to
independent candidates, including 88 seats to the banned but
usually tolerated Muslim Brotherhood... Secular opposition parties
got nine seats: six for the Wafd party; two for the Tagammu; and
one for the Ghad...
Polarized
politics: Analysts
are providing varied takes on the elections and what they mean... First
of all, there's dreamy rhetoric
by the ruling NDP about how Egyptians are living in the midst of a
marvelous awakening... AP speculates
about what the Muslim Brotherhood might do with their newfound
power... The Guardian argues that strong brotherhood results will reverberate
across the region... A Daily Star commentary outlines why people
should come
to terms with the brotherhood's gains... Other
analysts say politics have been polarized....
The Washington Post looks at how the shift
from secular to religious opposition occured... The
brotherhood itself, meanwhile, says it's ready
to talk to Washington... The US says it's ready
as well. The US State Department
keeps up its wishy
washy talk about how violent the elections were...
The Post is far more forceful, calling the last days of the
election shameful...
Saad Ibrahim also pens some tough
words in the LA Times... Some AP
analysis
of the violence and what it means about Mubarak's commitment to
democracy... NY Times wonders who used live
ammunition... Finally,
Islam Online looks at how the press
covered the results...
Plus, more...
And the verdict
in Ghad party leader Ayman Nour's trial will be announced on Dec.
24.
Ayman Nour still
awaiting sentencing...
3rd
round of parliamentary polls
Chaotic
conclusion
Eight dead. Dozens
injured. The last day of month-long parliamentary elections was a
day of chaos. There were even officers on rooftops preventing
voters from climbing in through poll station windows, after they were stopped
from casting their votes at the doors. It ended with the Muslim
Brotherhood still winning even more seats, bringing their total to somewhere
in the high 80s. The ruling NDP also looks to have secured more than
the two-thirds majority it needs to control the assembly.
Meanwhile, the media is really pushing this battle hard; here's a breathless paragraph
from AP:
"In the northern Sinai town of El-Arish, police blocked
Brotherhood voters from polling places Wednesday and many fought
back with a hail of stones and firebombs, cornering police in the
narrow streets of the Mediterranean city." Similar stories
are also told by AFP
and Reuters.
The Washington
Post is on the scene in one town, while blogger Baheyya
provides a rather dramatic narrative overall.
"Is
it perfect? No."
Lots of violence reported
and photographed
during
last round... (Earlier
run-off
stories from AFP,
Reuters,
and Yahoo...)
Meanwhile, the US State Department gently ups its rhetoric
on Ayman Nour, parliamentary elections, and the whole Egyptian
democratic reform process... Here's the transcript
of the new US response, which AFP calls a "blast".The US
is concerned
about the fact that Ayman Nour has been detained
until his trial ends Saturday...
Not quite over
yet...
The Los
Angeles Times
takes a much closer look
at the
controversial elections
in Damanhour... The Muslim
Brotherhood accused the government of detaining more than 1,250
of its supporters during ongoing parliamentary elections in
retaliation for its success at the polls... Washington Post's
Jackson Diehl steps in with a harsh
look at the elections and what they should signify to the US...Meanwhile,
a rights group said US failure to criticize Egypt over the arrest
of opposition activists and the intimidation of voters in
elections has made a mockery
of Washington's commitment to Middle East democracy...
"Only
nine
candidates won outright in the first round of voting third and
final phase of parliamentary elections while the vast majority of
seats up for grab would have to be decided in run-offs...
Eight candidates from
the National Democratic Party (NDP) and one from the opposition
Wafd party won outright... Some 3.4 million voters, or 32.1
percent of the overall 10.6 million registered, cast their
votes... The turnout was a little higher than the around 25
percent witnessed in the first two phases of the elections... A
total of 136 seats were up for grab in the third phase and the
remaining 127 seats will be decided in run-offs due to be held on
Wednesday." Meanwhile,
police
have detained 170
people and charged them with inciting violence during
parliamentary elections... Plus, independent poll
monitors will be able to watch ballot counting by closed-circuit
television cameras in all future Egyptian
elections, a court ruled...
More of the same...
Egypt's ruling National
Democratic Party
is close to clinching the
2/3 parliamentary majority it needs to
maintain control over the constitution... No
immediate seats for the Muslim Brotherhood, but
"35 [of their] candidates will compete in runoff elections
next week to decide seats in races where nobody got more than half
the vote Thursday..." Meanwhile, the brotherhood cries
foul
and the US State Department cant
quite make up its mind about whether the elections were fair (Read
this transcript...)
Albright says Islamists should be allowed
to participate... BBC looks at
various Egyptian and Arab newspapers reactions'
to the pollls... Plus BBC photos
from poll day... Journalists intimidated,
polling stations blocked, Muslim Brotherhood supporters harrassed,
and yet many people still very determined to vote. Plus,
police fire into crowd, killing one would-be voter and injuring
others... Look at reports from AP
& Reuters,
and a Yahoo slide show of pictures...
Meanwhile,
Reuters talks to voters who think America is being unfair.
AFP looks at voter discontent,
and a more whimsical
piece explores the effect of satellite TV...
Plus,
Ayman Nour tells AFP
that he is ready for jail...
Curtain really begins
to close on Nour...
Earlier
reporting from AP... BBC does an eve
of vote roundup, Reuters covers the Muslim Brotherhood roundup
(up to 1600
arrested), and Osama
El-Baz talks
about the Brotherhood... The group's leaders themselves start to speak
up about their
future ambitions.. Earlier,
AP calls the Muslim Brotherhood's picking up 29 more
seats a "stunning
result"... Group leader Akef tries to soothe
the West about the brotherhood's foreign policy inclinations...
(Here's the longer
version...)
Plus interesting analyses of the results from bloggers at Arabist,
Baheyya,
and
Sandmonkey...
There's also a Yahoo slide
show of election day photos, made all the more
poignant, perhaps, by this account
of the difficulties encountered by reporters and photographers
covering the polls. Meanwhile, the United States renewed
its "real concern" over violence in Egypt's
parliamentary elections, and "Egypt's
judges -- tasked with monitoring [the polls] -- have decided to deploy
on the streets in a bid to ensure access to
polling stations."
Recurring story?
In
Egypt's parliamentary runoffs on Saturday, police
prevented
opposition voters from reaching the polling stations in
Alexandria... Judges called for voting to be suspended
as a result... Despite this, the
Muslim Brotherhood's
vote rampage continued... Reuters says 28
more seats for the Islamist group, while AP says 25
in a far more detailed report... Some say the brotherhood is thriving
on public anger against Israel and the government's ties with the Jewish
state... In any case, the police detained at least 50
brotherhood members
on Saturday... Meanwhile, Nazif tries to stay on
message about reform despite NDP election losses...
The "strong showing by the Muslim Brotherhood in parliamentary
elections has caught Egypt's rulers off
guard and could shake
up politics in the biggest Arab country," Reuters says... CS
Monitor explores the idea of legalizing
the group... A Brotherhood big wig explains
the situation... (Direct link to the brotherhood leader's comment
in the Guardian...) One
interpretation for this sudden turn of events, was proffered by
Negad el-Borai, a human rights advocate and elections' monitor,
to AP: "The people are saying we hate the ruling party, we
hate the government and we
will get anybody to rule us except you."
Interpreting
the results... again
A few interesting comments on how democratic
the process might or might not be... And,
somewhat over-worked musings on US
influence on -- and reactions to --
the elections, featuring quotes like: "The
Americans have reassessed the situation and come to the
conclusion that fast and vigorous democratization in Egypt is
impossible and will work in an undesirable way..." Also, the United States expressed "real
concern", and said it expected the Cairo
government to ensure a vote free of intimidation. Meanwhile,
an angry judge makes election fraud clear...but
the Judges club call for army protection only
makes it to UPI..
Money and
"baltaga"
More election related violence
in Gharbiya... Meanwhile, a
man was killed
in a fight between supporters of two rival politicians
north of Cairo on Wednesday in the second death in violence linked
to Egypt's legislative elections... Plus, "the
European Parliament delegation which went to Egypt to witness the
first phase of parliamentary elections there has decided not
to go back for the final phase. The delegation felt
that there was little point in returning because of the negative
impressions it had on 9 November. These impressions have since
been confirmed by NGOs and subsequent events in Egypt..." According to the
NY Times: "The violence was seen as a government effort to create
chaos to prevent the Muslim Brotherhood from making
further gains in the second round of three-stage parliamentary
elections."
Nothing
but parliament
Egyptian police arrested 16
members of the Muslim Brotherhood early on Friday, a day before
another round of parliamentary elections... Around 540 Brotherhood
supporters have been arrested since the beginning of the
parliamentary elections earlier this month, and about 300 are
still in prison...
Judicial escalation?
The biggest election related news on Wednesday was the Judges Club request
for army intervention to guarantee the sanctity of polling
stations... Get links to early
Wafd and Filbalad's coverage of that on zahma.com.
Plus, more
details
on election day battles from CSMonitor... 150 brotherhood members still
being held...
Heading into
Saturday's run-offs in the second stage of the 2005 parliemantary
elections, most political chatter is about the increasing gains
being made by the Muslim Brotherhood. The group's spokesman
Issam al-Aryan told AFP his movement "had won at least 13
seats in the second phase of the elections, without runoffs
needed, bringing their seat tally to 47,
trebling their 2000 score even before the elections' third and
final stage."
On TV all afternoon
Sunday, in conversations around town... there's more interest than
usual in the parliamentary goings-on... Here's
AP's election sum-up...
and a Yahoo slide-show of election day scenes...
(Earlier reports below...)
2nd round of parliamentary
elections..
With
1,706 candidates competing in 72 constituencies in 9
provinces ... AP reports initial
complaints of irregularities... Unknown thuggery
and fires in Alexandria... (More..,
a little
more..) Meanwhile, police detained more than 80
supporters of an Islamist candidate... This report says 200...
(More...)
1st stage
election results..
"Egypt's ruling party won 112
seats in the first stage of the country's
parliamentary elections, or about 70 percent of those
available... The
Muslim Brotherhood doubled their parliamentary seats in the
elections' first round alone, bringing concerns of what parliamentary debates will
be like, and whether or not the government will crack down on the
group in the next 2 rounds... Slightly
differing takes on the issue from AP,
AFP,
Reuters
and BBC...
Newsweek looks at post
election Ayman Nour...Meanwhile, journalists
were reportedly harassed
during the parliamentary elections... Probably a good thing, then,
that the US ambassador -- according to
Khaleej Times -- went undercover
to monitor the elections in Zamalek...CS Monitor
looks at the attack
on a Jazeera journalist and other violations against the press
during the heady election season...
Several violations
were observed during the first phase of Egypt's parliamentary
elections, the vice president of the European Union Parliament,
Edward McMillan-Scott, said."The
Cairo Institute for Human Rights Studies monitored state
controlled media during the election campaign. The result
surprised even the monitors: Broadcasters and newspapers dedicated
between 58
and 95 percent of their election coverage to the
ruling National Democratic Party... Post editorial takes
Mubarak to task for not keeping promises, says US should nurture
pro democracy movement and not regime...Most
NDP stalwarts
retained their seats... The Nov. 9 results in
the electoral districts of Waily, Boulak el-Dakrour and Manshiat
al-Qanater were invalid
and the polls should be repeated, the court ruled... Workers
doubtful
of election jobs pledges...Reuters looks at a few Gamal scenarios...
Judges
report on presidential elections comes out... VOA looks at young
people's participation in politics...
Plus, this from AFP:
"Egypt's Muslim
Brotherhood is set for a showdown
with the ruling National Democratic Party (NDP) in Sunday's second
round of parliamentary elections after making strong gains in the
first phase... Observers warned Thursday that [the regime] would
seek to prevent the Islamist movement from making further gains in
the two remaining rounds..." Soon
thereafter, there were reports that police detained
four Muslim Brotherhood members for distributing pamphlets...
Harsh run-offs...
Violence
and fraud mar parliamentary run-offs, including: 17 wounded in
election day scuffles in Beni Suef; a woman shot and injured
outside a polling station in a working-class area in Cairo; and
the burning
of a ruling party office in a lower income Cairo district...
Here are different
versions of a messy Tuesday vote
from AFP,
AP,
BBC
and Reuters...
Polls open in runoff
elections to decide 133 seats in Egypt's parliament...
80% of seats go to run-off ...
CS monitor
says turnout
was low but elections were relatively clean...Ayman
Nour loses
his seat and other early results... More from AP...
Police arrested
seven taking part in a Muslim Brotherhood protest on Friday
against what the Islamist opposition group says were rigged
elections...
The first round
is over: AP
and AFP
look at the interesting mix of more monitors, more campaigning and
some scattered violence...Mubarak's
party expected to win,
says Reuters.. which also reports that judges doubt turnout
figures, which initial reports said were better
than expected... Meanwhile,
here's a Yahoo slideshow of election
day scenes...
Ready,
set, vote...
First
stage of parliamentary elections start....
Mubarak urges big
turnout. AP says his "promise to open up the Egyptian
political system after nearly a quarter-century of his autocratic
rule faces a
major test"...Brotherhood
candidates pull
out of some races to make way for larger opposition
front... Looking
closer at the women
candidates... FT
says "elections unlikely
to dent ruling party’s majority"... And AFP
goes symbolic:
"Dove or tank? Tennis racket or mobile phone? In Egypt, where
close to half of the population is believed to be illiterate, a
good choice of campaign symbol can be decisive on polling day."
PARLIAMENTARY
ELECTIONS 2005:
Changing dynamics...
THE VOTING
PROCESS: Egyptians will cast their ballots in transparent
boxes in parliamentary elections scheduled for November...NGOs sue
electoral commission over monitoring...Egyptian
opposition groups which have formed an alliance to fight November
parliamentary elections want
international human rights organisations to monitor the vote...Egyptian
rights groups said they had recruited thousands
of people
to monitor the November parliamentary elections... Meanwhile, Egypt has decided to allow local
civic groups to monitor the November legislative
elections if they have approval from a government-backed human
rights council...
WHO TO VOTE FOR:
On the eve of the
elections, VOA looks at the opposition
front... Ahram's Hala Mustafa
pens a critical democracy
piece in the Washington Post... AP does a
"campaign heats
up" story...FT takes on the NDP's old
guard/new guard dynamic... AFP fetes Gamal Mubarak
as NDP opens
its parliamentary campaign season... Up to a fifth
of the People's Assembly are wealthy businessmen... Copts feel left
out of politics....
MUSLIM
BROTHERHOOD: The
latest news agency take
on the Muslim Brotherhood's campaign methods -- by AFP -- makes
some interesting points...The
agencies love Makarem Eldery, the brotherhood's female
candidate... BBC looks at
the brotherhood's "Islam is the solution" slogan and
other mixtures of religion
and politics... The
Brotherhood is standing in only about a third
of parliamentary seats in coming elections, to avoid friction with
the country's ruling party, its leader said... A closer look at the only Muslim
Brotherhood woman
candidate (another
look by Washington Times)...Brotherhood getting more
leeway than usual ahead of parliamentary campaign...Leading
Muslim Brother Essam El-Erian to be released...Plus, Brotherhood takes to the streets in
pre parliamentary elections campaign march...Islamist
lawyer Montasser Zayat enters
the parliamentary fray...
THE GHAD PARTY:
Reuters takes its turn at dissecting
Ayman Nour's woes...Bribery
charges against Nour dropped...
Nour
says trial hampers
election campaign...
hopes to partner
with Muslim Brotherhood for parliamentary poll... Dirty politics, threatening tapes, and more on
Ayman Nour's demise -- chronicled
poignantly by the New York Times...
Plus, lots
of reactions in Arabic on zahma.com
PARLIAMENTARY
ELECTIONS 2005:
Changing dynamics...
1600:
Final candidate list...Final candidate list
released... over 5000
candidates might compete...
Bring
on the candidates...
The Guardian
suggests
that "in the interest of democratic reform, the Egyptian
government must allow its electoral rivals some success..."
Earlier, Egypt's ruling
National Democratic Party has announced it will replace a third
of its existing MPs ahead of next month's parliamentary election... Mubarak approves NDP
parliamentary candidate lists... Meanwhile, the
leader of Egypt's banned Muslim Brotherhood urged Egyptians to vote,
saying it may be a fair
race but he still warned voters to guard against forgery... Parliamentary elections to begin November
9...
Opposition alliance declared...
More
on the opposition alliance,
which also seems to included Kefaya... Earlier
report: "The Wafd, Tagammu and Nasserists and the Muslim Brotherhood
in addition to some eight other opposition groups have formed a National
Front for Change," Rifaat al-Said said. He
said that a common platform would be drafted but that the front
would not field candidates in its name to the elections next
month. "The Wafd, Tagammu and the Nasserists will in all
likelihood field candidates as part of a coalition while the
Brotherhood will field their own." Plus, BBC takes another look
at the would-be
Wasat party..
Interior
Minister Habib al-Adly set October
15 as the start date for candidates' registration...
Khaleej Times profiles a female
Islamist candidate...and Another massive
Islamist student rally...
Tough report...
International
Crisis Group calls first multi-candidate presidential elections a "false
start for reform".. Report summary here...AFP's
take...
Police clashed
with a group of 30 demonstrators demanding the immediate release
of political detainees...
Gamal next time? President Hosni
Mubarak's son, Gamal, has taken
credit for bringing in political reforms which
helped his father win Egypt's presidential ballot. AFP says "Gamal
further
stamped his authority on Egypt at the ruling
party's conference, declaring his camp's victory over the old
guard."
Meanwhile, VOA
asks
"Is Arab
Democracy Possible Without Islamists?"
Meanwhile,
"thousands of Islamist students demonstrated
across Egypt to demand that parliamentary elections next month be
free and fair, in a
new show of force by the banned Muslim Brotherhood... Protests
were staged at four universities in Cairo and several other cities
under the slogan "Together for reform: Free university...
Free country."
Condi says Egypt has a long
way to go on democracy...
Meanwhile,
a top State Department official speaks out about a
lot still needing to be done for Egyptian democracy...
Another
term
President
Hosni Mubarak, who has ruled Egypt for 24 years, has been sworn
in for a fifth term in office...
Street protest
follows swearing in ceremony...
Meanwhile,
Al-Karama
-- yet another new weekly
newspaper
and potential political party, appears....
Nour dismisses Ghad dissidents party
coup attempt... Nour back
on the stand...
"Judges on Monday ordered Egyptian
opposition leader Ayman Nour to appear in court again on Tuesday, taking
him away from a parliamentary session swearing in
President Hosni Mubarak, who beat him in September 7
elections."
Still interesting...
Saadeddin
Ibrahim pens a Washington Post op-ed piece calling on Washington
to put
more pressure on Mubarak...And the Post's
Ignatious talks to a
lot of people who matter about whether or not the
old authoritarian system is truly broken...
Plus,
Kifaya -- at a
year old... calls for opposition
coaltion...
The next round...
Egypt's legislative
elections will kick off on November
8 for three weeks, a government official said on
Tuesday...
Longish analysis
says regime shell has cracked
post elections...
Post op-ed
says moderate Islamists
playing leading role, urges US to take note...
Mubarak will
be sworn in next Tuesday...
IHT looks at what Ayman
Nour and the Ghad party might do after the vote... Trouble
within the Ghad party...Plus, AFP looks at Nour's manifold
woes and latest battles...as the Ghad party leader continues
to be widely feted by the Washington Post...
Plus,
Culture minister to stay...
leads AP to say reform will come slow.
Whitaker's
latest Guardian piece starts with a witty
joke about elections... Post-election
demo... Condi's "lukewarm"
comment on the elections, as described by the blogger known as Sphinx...
Mubarak's
first post-election speech speaks the language
of democracy... San Francisco Chronicle
looks at the bright side, that things are changing..
Washington
Post is skeptical, citing the reality of a family wracked
by an unfair imprisonment. Globe and Mail finds brotherhood
upset
as well..
Another
interesting Globe and Mail story
combines
the following elements: Elections were rigged but not enough to
mandate overturning them... White
House congratulates Mubarak, but says it wants parliamentary polls
to be cleaner... Nour claims he
should have gotten 32 per cent of the vote... Post
election demo not attacked by police...
Announcing
the victory... President Hosni
Mubarak
was the unsurprising winner of Egypt's first multi-candidate
presidential elections. The election commission chairman announced
the results late on Friday: Mubarak
got 88.571 percent of the vote, Ayman
Nour of the opposition Al-Ghad party was second with 7.3 percent, followed
by the other main opposition candidate Noaman Gomaa of the Wafd
Party with 2.8 percent.
The turnout was 23 percent. Here
are takes from AP,
Reuters,
& FT.
Post
election coverage...
Great
intro from the Economist: "It was a lopsided
fight, hastily arranged, poorly refereed, and pitting a big
bruiser against bantams."
FT also has it
right: "Rarely is it clear in an electoral exercise such as
the one that took place yesterday in Egypt - an entrenched
autocracy dressing up a predetermined outcome with democratic
trappings - whether this should be dismissed as a farce or
embraced as a modest beginning. Because
it can be both."
Interesting
details in the New York Times account...
Whitaker's
Guardian piece is a good sum up of the New
Mubarak and the new Egypt...
Is it
over...
... or just the start?
The
polls have closed. Nearly
10,000 of them, across the country. It was a day unlike any other
day -- 24 hours that ushered Egypt into a much more democratic
realm... regardless of whether or not the first presidential
elections in its history were fair or not.
Even though the winner was known in advance, something has
changed, that's for sure: the public is still nowhere near being
in control of the process, but the door to that control room has
been opened, if only just a bit... Read
more
Last
estimate...
Opposition
candidate Ayman Nour — whose respectable showing for
a relative unknown could propel him to greater
political prominence.
-- wants a re-run...
and
authorities reject
his request...
Plus, expats upset
about not being allowed to vote...
and the US
State Department wants Mubarak to fulfill
his campaign promises if he wins...
Marring the
poll: AP's sum up concentrates on fraud
and a boycott rally... AFP says abuse...
BBC says apathy...
Mail and Guardian talks to confused
voters...
Monitors complain of harassment...
At one point,
the election day kefaya demonstration was attacked by thugs... AP
photo here...
Detailed Independent account
here...
Blogger
Mohamed, From Cairo, with love, writes an astute, emotional
account of how
the elections affected his day...
Plus, a
historic
look at elections in Egypt...
Election
day!
Early
poll station reporting from AP,
which also reports that no
protests are allowed today. The possibilities of a second round
explored by The
Independent.. Time predicts
that "Despite its flaws, Egypt's presidential election on
Wednesday could be the beginning of the end of one-man
rule"... Tribune says "Taste of democracy today
may whet
Egypt's appetite for more"... LA
Times, meanwhile, quotes many as saying "life without
[President Hosni] Mubarak is unimaginable."
Plus, Saadeddin Ibrahim
pens an op-ed
piece in the Daily Star... and there's a photo
of Prime Minister Ahmed Nazif confidently answering questions
about the elections at a Tuesday press conference... (Is Nazif's
sudden ubiquity the key to the rumors about Trade Minister Rachid
becoming Prime Minister... does it mean that Nazif -- who
certainly doesn't look like he's about to get the boot -- might be
named Vice President after Mubarak wins?) ..
The night
before... Mubarak's
victory
a foregone conclusion ... Overview mood piece
from Baltimore Sun... Another last
act story from AP... Washington Post op-ed stresses
that Bush needs to keep his eye on
Egypt after
the election as well... Interview
with human
rights leader on monitoring
plans... Worried
about voter fraud... Monitors and
congressional delegations... Mubarak's
final
campaign speech... Plus,
growing criticism
of president...
The
ultimate
election news coverage roundup...
Six Egyptian
non-governmental rights groups on Saturday urged Egyptians either
to boycott the country's first multi-candidate
presidential election this month or to cast their ballots against
President Hosni Mubarak...HRW of two
minds on election..The Egyptian judiciary
authorised local non-governmental
organisations to monitor the historic September 7
poll, a decision hailed as a major step towards ensuring a more
transparent election... Judges to supervise, buy say they cant guarantee
a fair vote...
One candidate eliminated
from race.. Photos
of all the candidates... Picture of the ballot...
Article on potential turnout
figures... Taking an in-depth look at the Wafd's slogan...
Interesting
comment from Washington Times on the elections, including many
opinions from top analysts...
This report says that Gamal Mubarak appears more powerful than ever, steering not
only his father's campaign, but also leading a silent
revolution inside the ranks of the ruling National Democratic
Party... Economist says "The
election may not be the real thing yet, but it's a pretty good show."
More...
election
media
Photo of
the strangest
of the candidates... Nour's campaign clip not
allowed to run... Judges not happy
about election rules...
PLUS:
"Washington's drive for democratic change in Egypt has left
the country's reformist opposition torn between
a deep-rooted anti-Americanism and the potential windfall of US
support..."
"... The
United States pressed
Egypt to allow independent observers to monitor next week's
presidential elections but played down opposition complaints of
unfair coverage by the country's media..."
Meanwhile,
police have been ordered to exercise "maximum
self-restraint'' during Egypt's first contested
presidential campaign and to prevent a repeat of attacks against
opposition protesters, reformist Prime Minister Ahmed Nazif said..
AND:
"Egypt's largest opposition group will not compete in the
country's first contested presidential election, but the
officially banned Muslim Brotherhood has its eyes trained on the
upcoming parliamentary
polls."
Media maxing on
election coverage?
Post columnist not that impressed
with the democratic experiment... Profile of looniest
candidate... The only thing bothering Mubarak on the campaign
trail is the heat...
Criticism of Mubarak on Egyptian TV...
Media in general slammed for being too
pro-Mubarak... AFP asks how transparent
the poll will really be...
Election
coverage roundup....
NY Times does an interesting elections mood
piece... Well-known writers, musicians and theatre figures gathered
along with hundreds of fellow artists in Cairo to protest... More kifaya
protests...Egyptian civil society groups are battling
for official recognition to monitor, but say the authorities have so far been
uncooperative despite vowing a transparent vote... The Muslim Brotherhood, blocked from fielding its
own candidate, is keeping
a low
profile until November parliamentary polls to avoid conflict
with the authorities... On the campaign trail
with Ayman Nour... Khaleej Times says voters not
really interested...
Latest
campaign details...
Egyptian President Hosni
Mubarak's election campaign ruled
out any televised debate between Mubarak and rival
candidates before the country's first contested presidential
elections on September 7.
Muslim
Brotherhood decides not
to boycott poll, but says it
wont support Mubarak either...
Khaleej Times
does a good roundup of election campaign starts, including Nour's shadow
government announcement...
Analyzing support
AP tries to find out why people in Boulaq
are supporting Mubarak... Shaaban
and Adel Imam also lend their support...
Banned Muslim
Brotherhood, meanwhile, will not
back Mubarak in Egypt's first contested
presidential election because they say he failed to deliver
political reforms.. Plus, biting column on the contradictions
in the brotherhood's political reform philosophies... and IHT
looks at the banned but tolerated group...
Who's taking the half million subsidy and who isn't? Campaign
funds becoming big
issue
Former US
ambassador Welch
comments on the upcoming elections...
Campaign
begins...
Reuters
seems to sum things up best... "Egypt's first contested
presidential election campaign opened on Wednesday with little
fanfare and few signs the race is likely to excite
millions of Egyptians after 50 years on the sidelines of politics."
Among the
interesting tidbits... "Egyptian state television, the main
source of news to many of the country's 70 million people, did not
broadcast [Mubarak's] speech, under new rules meant to ensure a
level playing field."
AP's version
has more details... including "Nour laid out his own
political agenda in a speech just after Mubarak, arriving in a horse-drawn
carriage to his campaign headquarters in an
impoverished neighborhood of central Cairo."
... and more
from AFP
Critics are
worried coverage
will be unfair....
Daily Star
editorial is critical
of the presidential election process.... "Today marks the
start of Egypt's first ever competitive presidential election
campaign, more noteworthy for the slight novelty of the process
than for any uncertainty about its outcome. ... The 77-year-old
incumbent marks his 24th year of rule by having nine challengers
run against him, making the exercise akin to an array of Egyptian
beetle scarabs lined up next to the Sphinx."
DOMESTIC POLITICS
Group to monitor media fairness
during elections...
Russian media
covers government subsidies
for candidates... Khaleej Times criticizes
Egyptian refusal to allow international monitors...
Washington Post encourages US to
keep its eyes
on Egypt.
Coptic Church decided to suspend
one of its priests, because he supports the opposition al-Ghad party, breaking rank with the church's official
endorsement of incumbent president Hosni Mubarak's presidential candidacy...
Cairo magazine banned
again...
The Post profiles Abuelela
Madi and his soon to be approved Al-wasat party...
Choosing the candidates
Meet the 10
contenders...
Talaat Sadat, 51, nephew of
slain former Egyptian president Anwar el-Sadat, says he'll quit
parliament if he's not allowed to run for president..
In the end he is disqualified...
Members of
Egypt's outlawed Muslim
Brotherhood movement are divided over whether to
boycott the forthcoming presidential election...
Gearing up for
an all-out media war in the run-up to the election, with no
less than six new newspapers due to hit newsstands
in the next few days...
AFP summarizes the almost
final list of presidential candidates... Only 11
candidates?
Details on the exact campaign dates, including the
possibility
of a run off if no one candidate wins 50 per cent...
Wafd announces chairman Noman Gomaa's presidential
platform...
AP photo..
And more on his views here...
Female
candidate talks about plans...
USAID funding goes directly
to local NGOs trying to monitor elections...
Kefaya supporting journalist arrested
by police... More strange incidents -- Ghad party says activist
shot in foot
by police while trying to put up posters in Benha...
Wafd enters the race...
First woman
to run... (more
about her here...) Arab columnist claims someone named Ayman
Anwar Sadat is running...
Artists
and writers stage an anti-Mubarak protest... Plus,
another kefaya demo, this one not
violent...
Earlier, an
insightful comment from BBC: "The assault on the protestors is yet
another mixed
message from a government which insists it is committed to
democratic reform, while its actions seem to advertise a limited
tolerance to opposition." Plus, a tough editorial
from the Boston Globe, Human Rights Watch highly critical...
and the US State Department comments...
DOMESTIC
POLITICS
Interpreting
Tahrir
Very thoughtful
Daily Star editorial fetes
and critiques Kefaya at the same time... Kefaya trying to come to
grips with protest
arrests, violence.... Muslim Brotherhood condemns
attacks on protestors...
AP story indicates clear confusion
among analysts over what comes next -- more crackdowns,
government not worried about US pressure, and news of more demos
on Sunday, this time relatively peaceful...
Plus, much more in
Arabic on zahma.com...
The
race begins...
Mubarak
and Nour bickering over who gets the crescent
symbol... Nour challenges Mubarak to televised
debate...
Media covers
news of the latest candidate
with absolutely no chance of winning...
The
incumbent will
run...
AP's report on President Hosni Mubarak's announcement
that he will be running for president again... Promises to fight terror...
Jazeera story features some reactions..
Critical
editorial in the Daily Star... Washington Post's sum up
of the scene... The Guardian tries
as well.
Unfortunate
events
AFP features
quotes
from protestors... AP features scathing commentary...
Reuters focuses on activists being detained...
This AP feed features a photo
as well..
Gumhoria
says Mubarak will
nominate himself...
Columnist
argues that Sharm emergency shouldn't be blank
check for democracy suppression...
AP says
bombings have meant
"Mubarak is projecting the image of a leader who may be the
difference between safety and strife" in the lead up to
elections...
Election
details set...
Disagreements
over sloganeering during large demo supporting judges...
Opposition
looks to boycott
presidential poll.. More from Daily
Star... And even more from the Guardian
and Khaleej
Times...
Unofficial
Islamist party Al-Wassat set to become legit?
Presidential
elections have been set for September
7...
Journalists being trained by USAID on how to cover
the elections fairly...
Saadeddin Ibrahim decides not
to run...
Saadawi also out
of the race...
Washington Post columnist closely links Bush
and Nour ... Plus, very
interesting PBS debate
between Nabil Fahmy and Saad
about fast versus slow
democracy, and foreign versus domestic pressure...
Different USAID? Andrew
Natsios, administrator of the U.S. Agency for International
Development, said that USAID money for civil society was
no longer subject to Cairo's nod.
Top US AID official clarifies the policy... "USAID's
job was to promote
democratic change as it had in countries such as Georgia, Ukraine
and Kyrgyzstan." Meanwhile,
Deputy Secretary of State Robert Zoellick sought to persuade
Egypt's leadership to accept international observers to monitor
upcoming elections...
DOMESTIC
POLITICS
Abdin
unemployment demonstration...
Opposition
groups -- including the Muslim Brotherhood, Egypt's largest and
oldest Islamic group, stood together with secular activists and
leftists -- last week to "call ... for all the political
forces to boycott
the elections...''
Demos take on another dimension...
Big opposition meeting calls for election boycott...
Khaleej Times interviews
Ayman Nour
Nour's
trial has been postponed
until after September's presidential poll, in which he intends to
stand.
Azhar Sheikh Tantawi upset
about sharia exemption in new political parties law...
Egyptian
opposition groups cast
doubt on the neutrality of people chosen to sit on
a commission which will have the last word on the conduct
of presidential elections in September. Washington
Post tries to sum up all the new protest movements and how
they operate...
Silent
MPs revealed by parliamentary report...
Imbaba unemployment
protest covered by AP...
Judges
speak up on referendum fraud...
Great first paragraph in Daily Star Egypt politics
analysis:
"You know that a country suffers distress and deep
distortions when the policemen at the airport ask foreign visitors
for tips and the waiters at the five-star hotels do not. When the
waiters are better trained and disciplined than some of the
security forces, you have a problem. Egypt today is a country with
problems, but also prospects for change."
Latest Ayman Nour...
"A
co-defendant in the trial of Egyptian opposition leader Ayman Nour
has withdrawn
his testimony, saying his confession had been forced out of him."
Earlier scenes
from the trial.
Anti torture
protest turns violent...
More from Reuters
Another
Egyptian expat
decides to run for president...Another candidate, Talaat Sadat, blasts
regime... Sadat's nephew
to run for president...
Muslim
Brotherhood wants to gather
opposition groups together.
Civil society rising...
Rights group
wants remaining Muslim brothers released....
Judges
saiy changes made to
law governing exercise of political rights ignored
their proposals to ensure convening of free and fair elections
later this year. Daily Star column looks at the issue more closely...
Sharq El-Awsat (in English)
has a first
hand account of the "free" kifaya demo in
Shubra...
Guardian's
take on the rare unmolested
Shubra protest. Plus, parallel Reuters
coverage.
Opposition leader
Ayman Nour was barred
from leaving Cairo to deliver a speech at the European
Parliament...BBC story also discusses the possilbility of Nour's disqualification from the
presidential race.
Latest
Condi reactions...
LA Times
analysis says US still choosing stability
over reform... Pat
Buchanan highly cynical
about Condi's Cairo democracy speech...More Condi fallout...
And, an interesting
comment: "But a recipient of American assistance has no
basis to protest ...
German media tries to put Rice
visit in context...
CS Monitor continues to pursue
the US's
reform role debate. As does Reuters...
Post columnist says that because Rice's speech was
so lofty
on US commitment to democracy, it might foretell the closing down
of Gitmo...And, an interesting
comment: "But a recipient of American assistance has no
basis to protest when informed, as the Egyptian
government was by Rice, that it “must fulfill the promise it has
made to its people — and to the entire world — by giving its
citizens the freedom to choose.... It is indeed the civilizational
challenge for Arabs, instead of dismissing Rice, to show their
hopes and dreams are no different than anyone else’s, and they
are no less deserving of freedom’s bounty."
The initial
press
coverage
AP's sum
up includes some negative audience reactions. The
Guardian looks at the issue, with a focus on why both the US and
Egypt agree the Muslim Brotherhood shouldn't
be officially included in the process. Plus, dull
coverage of Rice's meeting with the opposition. A
Boston Globe story asks:
''The question that is begged is, once you start spelling out what
your expectations are, what are you going to do if they are not
met?"
Unlocking the
door to change
US
Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice had praise for President
Mubarak and encouragement for his opposition, in the
continuing saga of conflicting US signals vis a vis the democratic
reform process in Egypt. Rice's
one day stop in Cairo was part of a regional tour that focused on
liberty in the Arab World. At the American University in Cairo,
where she delivered a "major speech" that was supposed
to give the Egyptian government a "bloody nose"
(according to a US official quoted by the press before the
speech), Rice spoke directly to the "Egyptian
people." It's “time
to abandon the excuses that are made to avoid the hard work
of democracy,” she said. Democracy
is hard to put into place, takes time...She used the US as an
example, and her own personal experience as an African American,
to show how long it can take to match the principles of democracy
with reality.
The US Secratary of State said
free nations would support democracy activists...
She
called them Cairo's "impatient
patriots".
This fall's elections must be
free and fair, she said, because the world is watching...There
must be unrestricted access for international monitors and
observers. Successful
reform is always home grown, and the government must put faith
in its own people, she said. Emergency laws must be replaced by
rule of law. Rice said
US presidents since Reagan have listened to Mubarak's advice.
She goes a little deeper into
Egypt's trend setting history, bringing up Mohamed Ali's
modernization regime in the 1800s, the Wafd's nationalist agenda
in the 1900s, and of course peace with Israel.
The
invitees included
Ali El-Smman, Naguib Sawiris, Khairi Bishara, Youssef Chahine,
Hassan Kami, Mohamed Abul-Enien, Ibrahim El-Moallam, Esmat
Abdel-Meguid, and Mustafa El-Fiki. Former US ambassador to Egypt,
now assistant secretary of state for the Middle East, David Welch,
was back in town with Condi.
The
sum up: It sounds
like the US has put the people in the Middle East in a pretty
tough spot. By Condi's own admission, the US has supported
dictatorships in the region for 60 years at the expense of
democracy. Now
that the US has seen the light regarding how dangerous that
attitude can be, they're asking the very same people who suffered
under that policy to come up with the rules of the new game, and
fight for what's right. But other than USAID, invading Iraq, and
strong worded administration statements, there isn't much clarity
regarding what the US is doing to ameliorate the situation it
helped create, and how all "free nations", as Condi
said, will support this process...
Stormy Monday?
US
official says "Rice will deliver a major policy speech in
Cairo and leave the Egyptian government with a "bloody
nose" on democracy." ... Guardian
features Abul Gheit's reaction
to US pressure -- "We want to be friends, but keep your
distance." ... FT
looks at conflicting
US signals towards reform in Egypt... Knight Ridder also analyzes,
and says Condi should visit the judges...
US
Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice -- in town over the next
few days -- plans meeting
with civil society activists, but, as the Post reports, "one
problem in arranging such meetings is that activists in the Middle
East are often leery of being publicly associated with the United
States." More details here...
The
Guardian, meanwhile, analyzes the potential impact
of Rice's trip: "At the
end of the conversation it's easy for
the Arab leader to say, 'You've made your case, now get off my
back and what are you going to do if we don't democratize?'''
"There's no good answer to that question.''
AP says anti regime
protests have brought secular and religious women together...
Over
400 more Muslim brothers ordered released...
Seeing
the light... The
Guardian has a lot on President Hosni Mubarak's plans
-- That he will seek a new term, and will appoint a civilian vice
president if elected, in an attempt to reduce military control over many
aspects of Egypt's governance... Will the military be upset about
this, the reporter also asks...
Meanwhile, there's also Reuter's take
on the whole thing, and an in-depth piece in the Independent tries to sum up
the scene vis a vis presidential
son Gamal. (The
Presidential spokesman later
denies the British reports...)
’Candidate
must prove he has clean financial record, certificate showing he
performed his military duties, signed declaration certifying he
does not hold second nationality.' ... This Middle East online
piece summarizes
the debate in parliament about the new presidential election law being tailored to fit
presidential son Gamal. A little more
from Khaleej Times...
Meanwhile, strange new candidates
enter the fray... More
on the big Mubarak billboards being taken down, and a big
conversation with Gamal...
77 more Muslim brothers released...
AFP reports
that "Female journalists who were molested by Egyptian
security on referendum day last month are being threatened
by the state over the complaints they filed..." More here...
Opposition movement tries folklore
in subdued protest attempt...
DOMESTIC POLITICS
VP move?
FT breaks the
news that Mubarak plans to appoint a vice
president following the September elections...
An earlier
report about the huge pro-Mubarak
posters disappearing
from Egypt's streets...
Globe and Mail
pens a thoughtful editorial on what might happen
post May 25 referendum beatings... Female NDP parliamentarian
tells NY Times that Mubarak was not
happy about the beatings that took place on referendum
day...
A meandering, sometimes
interesting Daily Star take
on Egypt and the paradox of American
democratization. A UPI piece
concludes: ""Mubarak sees the China
model" in politics... "He wants to introduce economic
reforms without political reform." Thoughtful
BBC piece talks to three prominent opposition politicians...
Meanwhile, Ghad's new
radio station attracts
media attention... Plus, this
is quite a strange and interesting development -- Korean
groups hold a kifaya solidarity rally in front of
the Egyptian embassy in Seoul...
163
Muslim brothers released from prison, but hundreds more
still detained... Post portrays
Washington's indecision
on Egypt democracy pressure as a contest between advisors
Saadeddin Ibrahim and Tarek Heggy regarding whether or not to
allow the brotherhood into the process...
Reuters reports that "Egypt's foreign minister said
most Egyptians were against the idea of foreign monitoring of its
first presidential elections this year but no decision
had yet been taken"
Reuters highlights the
new pro
Mubarak signs going up all over town...
Kifaya holds a
candlelight vigil at the sight of the 25 May referendum
beatings... Here are stories from AFP,
China,
and Reuters...
"Nomination
period for candidates for the presidential election slated for
September will open on July 18..." and more details on the
election process from Chinese media... Ayman Nour wants to be
president for two
years...
AFP looks at mushrooming
of new reform groups...Meanwhile,
a new high-level change
movement explains its reasons for stepping up -- "We are
against dictatorship, and against those who shut the door to
peaceful transitions, and those who mess with public money,"
said Yahia al-Gamal, a former government minister and member of
the new coalition."
Christian
Science Monitor tries to figure out the Muslim Brotherhood --
concluding that their democratic rhetoric might not be a trick.... Washington
Post flirts
with religious politics - "For the Bush administration, which
has called on Egypt to hold 'fair and free' elections, the
Brotherhood theoretically represents a viable partner in what the
president has called a 'march of democracy.'"
"Parliament rejected
an opposition demand to investigate attacks on protesters and
journalists during a referendum last month." Masry El Youm
voter fraud pics picked
up by Khaleej Times and agencies...
Columnist describes Egyptian
politics as having low grade fever.
With a focus
on Gamal Mubarak, Business Week tries to synthesize
the country's changing business and politics scene... Plus, the text
of Gamal's recent Amcham speech... Meanwhile, a home grown pro
Mubarak group appears...
And Kefaya threatens to seek legal recourse abroad...
Bush Mubarak phone
call...
Reuters
says the US President "urged"
the Egyptian leader to hold free and fair elections...AP calls it
"gentle
prodding" ...
The
raw data: Excerpts from the different White House press
conferences that mention it..."He's publicly stated he is for
free and fair elections, and now is the time for him to show the
world that his great country can set an example for others,"
Bush said. He also laid out what he called some reasonable
standards for free and fair elections: "Listen, the
definition of free and fair, there's international standards, of
course, but people ought to be allowed to vote without being
intimidated; people ought to be allowed to be on TV, and if the
government owns the TV, they need to allow the opposition on TV;
people ought to be allowed to carry signs and express their
displeasure or pleasure; people ought to have every vote count.
And those seem like reasonable standards." Bush's press
secretary meanwhile, said "so that's something that we'll
continue to watch as they move forward, and we appreciate the
commitment from President Mubarak to move forward on free and fair
elections."
Meanwhile, at the Journalist's
syndicate... "Hundreds
of Egyptians have staged an angry protest against the alleged
sexual harassment of female activists and reporters by government
supporters," reports BBC.
"Call for Resignation of Egyptian Minister," says ABC...
Daily Star's report adds some pre
protest government reactions... and here's AP's
mostly similar one to boot.
Egypt frees
22 Brotherhood members for exams
Egyptian Prime
Minister Ahmad Nazeef admitted
on Tuesday that "mistakes" took place during last week's
constitutional referendum, according to the Middle East News
Agency...
Bush comments
about Egyptian elections again...
and a Post commentator is critical of Laura Bush's timing...
Egyptian
activists have launched two
separate initiatives in protest against the assault
of several women during last week's referendum.
"Two
Egyptian papers. Same event. Different pictures. Different
tale." -- How Ahram and Wafd covered
the referendum...
Lebanese mags
look at referendum's low
turnout...
Gamal Mubarak avoids
the tough questions at Amcham seminar...
Government responds:
Reuters reports that "Egypt said on Saturday attacks on
activists opposing this week's referendum on adopting a new system
for presidential elections had been overplayed
by the media but that such incidents were still unacceptable."
Washington
Post profiles one of the women
who were assaulted by thugs during kefaya's referendum protest...
Plus, student
members of Muslim Brotherhood released...
The results are in: 83
per cent vote yes...
BBC's look
at what the press said
(mostly positive), and what the rest said
(mostly negative)... Reporters without Borders open letter
to Mubarak on press freedom violations....
This AP story says the
way the government handled the opposition to the referendum shows
the regime is on the defensive...
Not a very
positive image... Bush
upset
about the way the referendum was handled... The following is from
the White House transcript:
"Q:
Mr. President, President Bush, the First Lady under the Egyptian
pyramids this week enthusiastically endorsed Mubarak's first steps
towards direct presidential elections. Two days later, Mubarak
supporters attacked the opposition in the streets. Was it
premature to back Mubarak? What's your message to Mubarak now?
PRESIDENT BUSH: I also embraced President Mubarak's first
steps and said that those first steps must include people's
ability to have access to TV, and candidates ought to be allowed
to run freely in an election and that there ought to be
international monitors. That's -- and the idea of people
expressing themselves in opposition in government, then getting a
beating, is not our view of how a democracy ought to work. It's
not the way that you have free elections. People ought to be
allowed to express themselves, and I'm hopeful that the President
will have open elections that everybody can have trust in.""Mockery
of democracy is worthy of applause." -- This Washington Post
editorial is highly critical of Laura Bush...
COMMENTARY
An
interesting,
devastating experiment
by Tarek
Atia
How to sum up
Wednesday's referendum? The results will be announced Thursday
afternoon, but nobody's really holding their breath.
Wednesday's events featured
a standard variety of mishaps and contradictions. These included
loud cheers -- on TV, in the papers and on billboards across town
-- about the empowerment of citizens, about how voting in the
referendum on whether to have multi-candidate instead of
referendum-based presidential elections was the right thing to
do.
It didn't seem to matter if
you didn't know what the referendum was really about. Even
if you did, with
just yes or no options, you didn't really have much of a say about the specific details of amendment
76's conditions for future presidential candidates.
The avalanche of glib
commentary and lack of informed debate meant that, as usual, the
average person was on their own when it came to deciding who to
believe. The government or the opposition? Laura Bush -- who
called the amendment a positive step -- or her husband, who's
always pressuring for more?
You would have been hard
pressed to find answers in the superficial cheers surrounding the
amendment. And even the opposition's boycott campaign was obtuse,
with papers painting their front pages black and asking people to
stay home for an issue that they don't really understand.
People don't get it; not
because, as so many pundits will claim, they're too poor, or too
tired, or too frustrated. But because nobody -- NOBODY -- has ever
really bothered to tell the whole story in a reasonable, moderate,
and -- most importantly -- overly informative, rather than overly
emotional, way.
And that's where the
problem has always been. With different sides endlessly
sloganeering, the average person -- and the general welfare -- is
always totally left out of the debate.
Referendums
and rage...
And that's why you get
the scenes of violence that everyone is talking about -- the
usual Kefaya
protest
that soon got ugly... Second page of LA Times varied
coverage reveals their own reporter
was "groped and harassed by a crowd of pro-Mubarak
supporters, then forced to the ground and kicked in the stomach
and back. She escaped with bruises."
Oh but that's okay.
Ahram had warned,
after all, that security services would "forcefully respond
to any attempts to disparage the safety and security of the
nation." But like this? And resulting in coverage like this
from the CS Monitor: "A referendum
Wednesday that Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak's closest aides
said would show the world his regime is moving toward democracy
instead became a showcase
of the regime's tough tactics to jail, harass, and intimidate its
opponents." More news on activists and journalists
being pushed
and beaten from ABC... Plus,
FT's sum
up...
Meanwhile,
Mubarak and his family vote
in peace... while
SBS reports an overall low
turnout for the poll.
Plus,
the opposition is upset
about Laura Bush's support for Mubarak. Did her comments give the
government the green light to quash dissent? The Guardian seems to
think it's all Laura's fault...
The people watching at
home see most of this as a blur. And they will continue to, as
long as the media -- all media -- make no attempt to tell the
whole story. (Small examples: In the lead up to the referendum,
and on the day it took place, the papers were filled with
exhortations to go to your local poll station and vote; you didn't
need to be registered -- an ID card would do. Untrue -- at least
if the station was manned by a judge. Then you had to be on the
list. But then again, if it wasn't manned by a judge, you could
probably get away with it... 8 times even, as Wafd did (see zahma).
In any case, most of the coverage ignored the bigger issue with
the judges demanding more rights before agreeing to supervise the
upcoming presidential elections that the referendum is just a lead
up to...).
Overall: It was an
interesting, devastating experiment. Much like the political
turmoil of the past period has all been. And the way the future
will surely be. One only hopes that reason will play some part in
the events to come.
More details in Arabic on zahma.com
DOMESTIC POLITICS
Jackson
Diehl's latest in the Post paints
the Muslim Brotherhood as the last remaining Islamist group
in the Middle East not being let into the political process...
(Now Egypt is being urged to "lead the way" in the
region's political acceptance of Islamists...) The Post also focuses
on the brotherhood after the recent arrests... (More
brotherhood arrests.. extensions for leaders El-Erian
and others... And earlier,
even more brotherhood arrests...)
Plus, an
indecent brawl
during pro and anti Mubarak protests at Al-Azhar.
Today's
the day: The public will be
voting on the referendum to amend article 76 of the constitution
today... AP
interviews the
"man on the street", finds out he's
very confused
about what the referendum is all about. SF also does a roundup...
The Washington Post's
harsh anti-Mubarak story continues to paint Ayman Nour as a hero,
describing a makeshift rally his supporters tried to hold in front
of a downtown theater...
The US tries
to explain its stance in the wake of Laura Bush's remarks... Laura
calls Mubarak "bold",
applauds his slow and steady approach to democracy... Plus,
highlights from her speaking
to women leaders and visiting
the Bibliotheca.. And later, defending
her remarks on the plane home (plus more Sesame Street details
and a pic)...
German TV team detained
for several hours for filming kefaya...
More Muslim brotherhood
members arrested...
Reuters says group is taking the blows in stride..
Referendum
roundup
Voter turnout... AFP
tries to predict/analyze
voter turnout for Wednesday's referendum...
Lawsuits...
"Lawsuits asking
for a postponement of this week's referendum on a constitutional
amendment changing the way the Egyptian president is chosen"
are rejected
by the courts..."
Observers
not monitors... "Foreigners are free to observe
voting in Egypt's first multi-candidate presidential election in
September, but the government will not accept international
monitors having any role in the process, Prime Minister Ahmed
Nazief said Monday."
Mrs Bush's two cents...
Washington Post on Laura' pyramids tour and
positive comments about Mubarak.. More details on the Sesame
Street appearance... Plus, a harsh
reaction from a local commentator in the States, who thinks she
should have kept her mouth shut...
Amending article
76:
Opposition parties try
for injunction
on referendum...
Ayman Nour
joins referendum boycott...
Pretty good
BBC sum
up of the political scene... Another agency looks
at pro and anti Mubarak slogans...
Despite
Nazif's optimism, one correspondent concludes "In Egypt
today, the
hour is late."
Laura's tour: "She will travel to Egypt, after mixing praise with gentle
prodding on her way to the region by saying Egyptian President
Hosni Mubarak should set an example to the Middle East with fair
elections." More
from the Post, including the interesting quotes themselves... Her five-day visit
to the region -- which includes a guest appearance on Alam
Simsim, the Egyptian equivalent of Sesame Street --
will feature Mrs Bush promoting freedom and supporting women and
girls across the Middle East. More on the trip
from Knight Ridder...
Meanwhile,
Egypt gets a bad
gender gap score, and a critical
commentary from Khaleej Times...Plus, Egypt's National Council for Women
(NCW), a
government-affiliated group, has expressed skepticism
over the World Economic Forum (WEF) report stating that the country
has the largest economic and social disparity between the sexes of
almost 60 countries studied.
DOMESTIC POLITICS
More
raw data from
Nazif's visit to the States...
This transcript of
the Prime Minister's CFR
appearance features this incredible bit:
"QUESTIONER: Yes. Mr. Prime Minister, my name is Khaled Dawoud
from Egypt's Al-Ahram newspaper. I was wondering, sir,
whether you raised with President Bush this morning the issue of a
few Egyptian prisoners who are kept in Guantanamo. I mean, in
following up the controversy that we're having here in the United
States about the torture of prisoners, and whether you're seeking
them to be taken over to Egypt like the others that you've
mentioned in the earlier report. Thank you very much.
NAZIF: No, that problem didn't come up in the meeting with the
president today, but it's being dealt [with] through other
channels.
QUESTIONER: But do you want the six Egyptians or seven
Egyptians there back to Egypt, sir?
NAZIF: Excuse me?
QUESTIONER: Do you want the six or seven Egyptians--
NAZIF: Do I want them?
QUESTIONER: Yes, do you want them--
NAZIF: Depends how they look. I don't know. [Laughter]"
A
classic case of different interpretations...
Western press NYT
and IHT
portray US President Bush offering Prime Minister Nazif a free trade
agreement as a reward for election monitoring
and more reform... while most Egyptian papers say monitoring wasn't
even brought up...
Here's an interview Nazif gave to PBS
that may provide the answer to that money question:
"MARGARET WARNER: And did
he define what he meant by free and fair? He has said publicly,
for instance, he's called on Egypt to allow international
monitors. Did you discuss that?
AHMED NAZIF: He did mention it but we didn't
discuss it in any detail. But I think the sense is we and
the president as well share the view that we need to project to
the world that this is a free and fair election. Now, it takes
observers; it takes television cameras standing in front of
polling stations, whatever it takes."
Plus,
later in the interview, there was also this inevitable gem:
"MARGARET
WARNER: Do you think that the way the system is set up for this
election there will be a viable opponent to President Mubarak?
AHMED NAZIF: That's the big challenge... I think the president is
very popular in Egypt; that if he decides to run again, that he
will win with a comfortable majority. But, having said that, I'd
very much like to see the process in place, see a candidate that
comes out, not just to bad mouth the president, but to present an
alternative, to present another problem, to say to Mr. Mubarak,
you've been doing it this way, I'd like to do it that way; that
kind of thing would be very healthy.
MARGARET WARNER: Might you be that kind of
candidate in 2011?
AHMED NAZIF: That's not in my political agenda right now."
Brian
Whitaker skewers
the political scene in the Guardian, also penning a piece
about Egyptian police being "too forceful".
AP story
highlights the fact that the government is extremely unhappy
with the US giving money to political groups, even though it takes
money from the US itself. Kifaya,
others, upset
about Mubarak accusations
in interview with Kuwaiti paper... Plus, Washington
Post analysis of the Muslim Brotherhood is sure to elicit
some reactions... And more tough talk on the same
from CS Monitor...
Looking
at
the raw data
Election
monitors mentioned twice in the White
House
press briefing
following Prime Minister Nazif's meeting with Bush.
Here's one from the Q and A with the White House press
secretary:
"Q: The free trade agreement you're talking about with Egypt,
would it be conditional on Egypt taking election reforms that you
would like to see?
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, it's important that they move forward on
the political reform, and they had a very good -- the President
and the Prime Minister had a very good discussion about that. And
the President emphasized the importance of free elections where
you're going to have multiple parties and you can have full
campaigning. The President talked about the importance of that.
And President Mubarak has taken an important step by saying, we're
going to have competitive presidential elections this fall. And
the President also emphasized the importance of international
observers for that process, as well, to show the world that it is
free --"
Here's the White
House pic of the Nazif-Bush handshake, with portraits of Abe
Lincoln and George Washington staring them down... a
Reuters story
about the meeting... and more FTA
details from Daily Star... Plus,
don't miss Wafd's
critical take on zahma.com
Nazif in
Washington...
Washington
Times sums
up the scene: "President George W. Bush and
Egyptian Prime Minister Ahmed Nazif meet at the White House
Wednesday amid disappointment
over Egyptian political reform measures but also amid the reality
of needed Egyptian cooperation in the delicate Middle East peace
process."
Washington
Post sums up the scene if
there's no real reform: "The principal losers
will be not his opposition, but those who hope to save Egypt from
political upheaval."
More Nazif spin from the LA
Times. Plus, the prime minister is optimistic
about an FTA
with the US... And he
tells USA Today that "Mubarak's son, Gamal, will not run for
president this year but might run later. "Of course, it's
unheard of that the son of a president would become a
president," Nazif [then] joked in a clear reference to
Bush." Here's the full transcript...
which includes such gems as : "Q.
How many people are in the Mogamma (a huge government building in
downtown Cairo)? A.
20,000. In a year I may close it down. I'm
actually thinking of turning it into a hotel."
Earlier Nazif
was on Meet
the Press. Here are some highlights:
"MR. RUSSERT: Will Egypt allow international monitors
to oversee the campaign?
PRIME MIN. NAZIF:... Egypt is one of the few countries that has judiciary
supervision of the elections. That means that the
judiciaries are the ones that take care of the elections.
Judges in Egypt do not--they feel that having foreigners sharing
that with them will be an infringement on their own right of
supervising the election. So it's still a hot issue in
Egypt. I don't think...
MR. RUSSERT: ... you mentioned the
judges. They met yesterday, Mr. Prime Minister, and said
that the election is "a fraud," and they are boycotting
it because they do not think it will be a full and free and fair
election.
PRIME MIN. NAZIF: I don't think
that they meant that it's fraud. I'm not sure if this is an
accurate code. But I think what they said...
MR. RUSSERT: That's the word that
they used, and they cheered when they heard it.
PRIME MIN. NAZIF: What they said is
that they would like to have more power in supervising the
elections, which makes my point. They're looking for having
complete power in supervising the elections themselves. Now,
we didn't say no about that. We just said that it's a
process that has to take place through law. Now, a new law
will be coming out, because we're changing our constitution on May
25. After that, we'll have to debate that law in parliament
and make sure that it provides us with that. The emphasis is
we are, the government is, Mr. President Mubarak is, for a free
and fair election."
MR. RUSSERT: So the minor parties
will be able to run. They'll have complete and fair coverage
in the state-controlled media, access to the airwaves, access to
the ballot?
PRIME MIN. NAZIF: As head of the
Egyptian government, I promise you, Tim, this will be the case."
Boycotting
76
The Wafd, Tagammu and Nasserist opposition parties call to boycott
the May 25 referendum...
Arab
News looks at why
Egyptian expats will not be allowed to vote...
Plus, there's an image
of the new Article 76 ballot on zahma.com
Interesting comparison
The Daily Star's
Ramy Khoury writes: "Having experienced the street sentiments
of demonstrators and talked with leading activists in Egypt,
Lebanon, Syria, Palestine, Bahrain and others, I would suggest
that the most useful place to look for the inspirations that drive
Arab democracy activists these days is not the speeches of U.S.
President George W. Bush, but rather the
protest movements among American civil-rights activists in the
period 1956-1964. The emotional and political
sentiments that drive Arabs today to confront their autocratic
rulers, security services, or foreign occupiers are almost
identical with the instinct for political liberty and human
dignity that inspired the civil rights movement in the United
States two generations ago."
Confusion
over what Mubarak may or may not have said in the Kuwaiti
interview about Gamal...
In an interview with a Kuwaiti
newspaper President Mubarak says protests are hurting Egypt's
economy and will scare
investors away... Plus,
this is what Mubarak said about the Muslim Brotherhood --
"The people here are past the phase of misleading and they
understand how things go..." You
can find Mubarak's most interesting quotes on zahma.com.
Referendum on multi candidate presidential
elections set for May
25 -- lots of calls to boycott it... Opposition press reacts
with dismay...
Brotherhood will not nominate a candidate; it's leader tells press
he doesn't
agree with kefaya's tactics... The brotherhood also
denies overthrow
plans...Meanwhile, more brotherhood arrests...
and AP looks a bit closer
at the banned group
Cairo judges
insist on totally
independent supervision... or else they will
boycott elections. (more from BBC)...
Destour reported in this this week's edition that the US will
probably tell Nazif -- who's visiting Washington now -- to listen
to the judges or else... The paper says it got its information
from an "Egyptian thinker" who is currently living in
the US and who met with Dick Cheney on 9 May...
New dynamic?
Press notices top officials defending
themselves instead of staying silent, including very telling
comments from Prime Minister Ahmed Nazif to AP on the eve of his
US trip -- "It doesn't help a lot when somebody takes a
courageous step, and the first thing he faces is skepticism."...
Nazif,
like Mubarak, urges gradual
rather than hasty reform...
FT harsh on false
reform moves... Economist
thinks something more real might be stirring...
US-EGYPT
RELATIONS
U.S. President Bush touched a raw
nerve when he suggested the Egyptian government,
one of Washington's best friends in the Arab world, accept
international monitoring of presidential elections this year.
"It is
simply difficult to accept or swallow the
idea that the U.S. administration wants to change
the regime in Egypt ... Washington is eyeing positively President
Hosni Mubarak's reforms," said Nazif, who is scheduled to
visit Washington next week. The Guardian: "Egypt
is an important US ally in the region, they say, and the last
thing Washington wants is to enhance the power of
the Muslim Brotherhood."
Amending 76
LA Times: "It
means there is no change in the system," said Mohammed Sayed
Said, an analyst at the Al Ahram Center for Political and
Strategic Studies, a think tank. "Most people say, 'Why
bother? Why did the president propose the
amendment?' He gave with the right hand, and they took away with
the left hand."
CS Monitor's
pessimistic
take...
NY Times:
This is a political trick
which makes a mockery of democracy," said Mostapha K. al-Sayyid,
a political science professor at the American University of Cairo...
Chinese
media's take:
"It will not
affect Mubarak." Plus, CNN's brotherhood-centric take
on the debate that's about to end... FT's title is the best --
"Mubarak's party to vet
his opponent"
Impossible
conditions...
Reuters reports that lots of political forces agree about how hard
it will be to field presidential candidates based on the rules
parliament has set down regarding amending article 76 of the constitution
to allow direct multi party elections as promised by Mubarak...
Nour hints at bowing
out of the contest after supposed assassination attempt... Check out this telling
summation of US policy on election reform in Egypt, courtesy of
VOA... Compare with what
the so-called "New
Opposition"
means to the Chicago Times -- "As you know, Bush imagines
freedom will go hand in hand with peace for Israel. But in
reality, freedom will mean more resistance to American policies in
the region," Qandil said.
A whirlwind tour
Washington Times exposes the corruption
rumors surrounding Ayman Nour... Chicago Times celebrates
Nour and others fighting for change... Nawal El-Saadawi
complaining about being barred
for campaigning for president... CS Monitor looks at women
in Egyptian and Arab politics... LA Times looks at what the judges
want. Pat Buchanan predicts the triumph of anti-Western
Islamism in Egypt and elsewhere if democracy rules...
A little late,
but a fun
read nonetheless -- LA Times take on the Mubarak
interview.
Meanwhile, 50 more Muslim
brothers rounded
up, and the brotherhood vows
to continue protesting despite arrests... Plus, a photo of brotherhood
leader Akef from Reuters...
Essam El-Erian
among senior
Muslim brotherhood members taken into custody, announced his decision
to challenge
Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak in the September election, his
lawyer said Saturday, but the powerful Islamist group said it had
not endorsed the challenger....
Plus, hundreds
of Egyptian judges have rejected
U.S. President George W. Bush's call for international monitoring
of Egypt's September presidential elections, saying they will do
the job themselves...
Earlier reports had indicated that Bush, on a visit to Riga, Latvia, spoke of the elections in the
Middle East this year, including in Egypt.
"That election should proceed with international monitors and
with rules that allow a real campaign," Bush noted.
Washington Times
decides to assess Egypt's seriousness about refrom... "Even our government
handler is talking freely about the good and bad things the
government has done." The paper also comes clean about
accepting the invitation
from Egypt... As
part of the Washington Times coverage, Prime Minister Ahmed Nazif talks politics...
Some of the telling quotes: "There has been a little turbulence the last few months
because of Ayman Nour, [whose arrest was] an unfortunate event. I
would have preferred that it had not happened in the first
place... [but] it is not a political prosecution." ...
"Mr. Nazif acknowledged that some Egyptians will be unhappy
if the lack of a competitive race leads to a fifth term for Mr.
Mubarak, already in office for 24 years... But, he said,
"I think President Mubarak as a person has national
acceptance. People will be angry because they want change, not
because it's President Mubarak."
Nazif also
tries to impress
Knight Ridder at his smart village office... and previews his
upcoming trip
to the US with top editors...
Attack updates...
Key Independent sum
up of Cairo post terror incidents:
"Islamist groups in Egypt have undoubtedly been
radicalised by the American occupation of Iraq and have become
markedly more hostile to Westerners. Domestic frustrations are
also a likely factor."
UK ups its
travel advisory warning level...
Italian site carries Moheet linkage
of Cairo and Doha attacks...
An
Australian report concludes with this chilling paragraph:
"It is the worst
of times to be launching a tentative experiment in
political relaxation, and yet that is just what Egypt's Western
allies are clamouring for. As the smoke from Saturday's attacks
clears, the context of Egypt only becomes more murky. And the
capacity of terrorism to disrupt Arab regimes without destroying
them is highlighted once more."
Devastating day
Saturday was an awful day
in Cairo, with two attacks taking place...
The first was in the vicinity of Tahrir, where a "bomb
was thrown from a Cairo bridge to the street below not far from a 5-star
hotel and the Egyptian Museum, killing an Arab man and injuring seven
people, including four foreigners, authorities said." More
from AP...
The second was an attack on a bus by two women in niqab, at least one of
whom was killed by police.
Bloomberg's version says that
three
militants died in the attacks...one being one of the three
suspected of taking part in the recent Muski blast... More on this from Gulf
Times..
CNN says 200
people from the home villages of the attackers have
been detained. Another Reuters story discusses the
"specter
of militancy" returning to Cairo...
BBC
reports on a government denial that the attacks represent a return
to violence; they are categorized instead as related to a security
crackdown on the group that planned the Muski
bomb... Jazeera coverage says much the same, extensively quoting commentators
as saying that the way police handle
investigations (mass detentions, torture, etc) had
a lot to do with it. As if on cue, here's a Reuters's story saying
the cousin of one of those accused in the Muski attack died while
in police
custody... And here's more on the attackers' family
connections...
A foreboding sentence in a Time story:
"The police believe that the symbol-rich
site of Yassin's attack — a central square facing
Mubarak's ruling National Democratic Party headquarters, the famed
Egyptian Museum that contains the treasure of Tutankhamen and a
skyscraper hotel named for Egypt's most powerful ancient pharaoh,
Ramses — was chosen at random."
More Saturday fallout
The typical story -- AP looks at how an ordinary
happy teenager turned
into an angry fundamentalist...
AFP focuses on the women
terrorists factor... The Abdalla Azzam brigades take responsibility...
The complicated
situation on the street... Plus, this story says "Egypt has stepped up
security around its popular tourist sites. The tourism ministry
had set up a crisis
cell to monitor developments and make contact with foreign
tour operators."
Reuters says tourists are unfazed
and will remain... Plus, predictions on possible
effects on tourism from UK's Independent...
And finally, an AP
sum up of Saturday's
sordid events...
DOMESTIC POLITICS
Media
savvy move?
Mubarak's Emad
Adib-hosted, Sherif Arafa-directed 7-hour TV
special was and remains the talk of the town this week. The surprise announcement
that had been hyped in Sunday's papers turned out to be the
president allowing the cameras into Air Force control rooms where
he recounted his career as a pilot and the lead up to the 73 war
during the first episode... The
second episode
of the
marathon Mubarak interview aired Monday night. It was
mainly about the president's transition from military man to
politician.
The big "surprise" in the
third and final installment of
the TV special was
the president choosing not to reveal whether he will be running
again this year. AP's
take on the Mubarak interview emphasizes the president's lively "new
look".
Destour called the show the beginning of Mubarak's
presidential election campaign..
Reform
wrap-up
Shows of force?
Muslim Brotherhood demonstrate for reform... News agencies
provide observations on a series of nationwide protests by the
banned group on Wednesday that in some places turned violent and
resulted in arrests: from AP
(read this other AP version for several missing paragraphs),
and SBS.
AFP's kifaya
protest summary...
BBC says 75 activists
were arrested at Wednesday's
nation wide kefaya protests -- most were later
released. CS Monitor provides a multi-faceted
analysis, linking Mubarak's TV special with the kefaya
demos.. A Washington Post analysis focuses
on Ayman Nour... Reuters provides a steady
take, and AFP's look at Mubarak's "charm
offensive" features an interesting quote from Mustafa
Kamel El-Sayed... Plus, tough talk from Maria Golia in the Daily Star
"...presidential
pretenders face serious restrictions. Mubarak may have invited
them to play ball, but not before tying
their shoelaces together...." Plus, a very interesting
development -- old
school democracy advocate and former free officer Khaled
Mohieddin may run for president as the Tagammu party candidate.
More demos in Arish
demanding release
of uncharged prisoners... Plus, 2 more
Muski bomb suspects named... And more
on these latest developments from Arab news...
Arab
News sums up the debate in parliament over amending
article 76... NY Times
also summarizes the presidential
election amendment scene,
with a focus on Mubarak and Ayman Nour... A top Ghad party official,
meanwhile, pens a tome
on political reform in the Daily Star.
Muslim Brotherhood
leader backs
Mubarak, despite having 28 of his group's members arrested. (Update:
4
released)
For more details, check the
Middle East online report.
Earlier, Middle East Online
previewed the special,
news of which first started spreading after a story appeared on the front page
of Friday's Ahram.
Knight Ridder does the obligatory Ayman
Nour profile, focusing on all the bad press he's been getting
recently...
Cairo University
professors make
a move, hold demo against security intervention in
campus affairs...
Journalists get
jail terms for libeling
a minister... New daily paper Masry El-Youm
campaigns to fulfill presidential promise to end the practice.
FT takes on the judges'
independence challenge story... Judges up the throttle on demands
for greater independence in presidential and parliamentary
elections.
The US has just welcomed
the recently-released internal human rights report...
The press is
still amazed
that the government-backed human rights council was so critical of
torture in prisons and the emergency law...
Obtained by Reuters, the new government affiliated human rights
council report is tougher
on the government than expected. Human Rights Watch, meanwhile, say lots of people
are being arrested.
Prime Minister Nazif is
quoted by Reuters as saying that candidates will be given equal
media time in the upcoming elections...
The scenarios abound in a
rollicking DPA
piece that claims,
"Among
the political elite, in popular coffee shops that exist in almost
every street in Cairo, or on university campuses across the
country, the main topic of discussion is whether President Hosni
Mubarak will run for a fifth term.
"...
The
Guardian takes a tour of a one
day whirlwind of demonstrations at Egypt's
universities.
Meanwhile, is
there a strange deal
being drawn with the brotherhood? Reuters talks to a top member
about demo and elections plans...
Egyptian judge's club make strong reform stance.
A detailed
Wall Street Journal feature on US
democracy grants to Egypt (not sure how long the
link will remain free)...
Simultaneous
protests demanding reform in five different universities.
Earlier, there were reports that 2
people were arrested
in the lead up to the protests...
K-R tackles Arish
mass
arrests story..
Mubarak will announce whether or not to run after
the referendum on constitution article 76.
Incisive Daily Star commentary on the realities
of reform. Another interesting
take from All Africa
Pakistani paper features intense discussion of emergency
laws
And, suddenly, out of the blue, Reuters in London reports on
Mohmaed Farid Hassanein helping to form a campaign seeking to put
pressure on Egypt to reform from abroad...
"Change for Change ...
Not for Bush," is one of the slogans that were yelled at
a 3-400 person American University in Cairo protest covered by the
press. Short entries by AP
and AFP. Hassan
Abu Taleb in Hayat analyzes the security
situation...
AFP
sums up the increasing defiance
on the political scene... CS Monitor looks at the irony in
the fact that most of the demonstrators being feted by the US as
nascent democratizers are actually very anti
US... Activists talk to Reuters about police abuse...
Plus, an interesting mix of people fighting to eliminate the emergency
laws...
BBC features brief
but colorful coverage of Wednesday's kefaya
protests, which didn't quite go as planned. Reuters says 25
people were arrested. Plus a few more details
and a pic from AFP. The
ruling NDP,
meanwhile, says Mubarak should run; the opposition predicts
big changes if he does...
The
government-Muslim Brotherhood power dichotomy
is explored by FT. The
Brotherhood says 200
of their members and supporters were arrested before,
during and after Sunday's demonstrations...
In somewhat related notes, AP does a
biting, telling take on
the authoritarian
political climate. There's also a very interesting New York Times
bit on the linguistics
of the kifaya -- or enough -- movement. This article says kifaya stirred
the brotherhood into action.
Plus,
an extremely thoughtful piece by a visiting American law professor
on reading between the lines of Bush's influence on democracy
in Egypt.
Plus, US
Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice's comments about the US caring
more about democracy than stability,
inspire lots of negative reactions from Cairene political
analysts, one of whom -- Mohamed Sayed El-Said --suggests that the
concept reflects an Israeli view of the region...
...
MORE WEB LOG
MARCH
17
Dina
Powell and the obsessed Post
MARCH 15
Egyptomania,
Bright Star and Azhar Park
MARCH
13
Protest
nation
MARCH
11
Abul-Gheit
finally speaks up
MARCH
9
Mido
and the shoe bomber
MARCH
7
Ramsis,
Tut and the winds of democratic change
MARCH 5
Coptic
resolution
MARCH
3
Egyptomania
and more, part 2
FEBRUARY
27 - MARCH 1
Mubarak proposal reactions
FEBRUARY
25
Lots
of miscellaneous
FEBRUARY
23
Egyptomania
and more
FEBRUARY
21
Complicated
conference
FEBRUARY
19
Post
Sharm moves
FEBRUARY
17
Controversial
politics
FEBRUARY
15
Ghad's
woes
FEBRUARY
12
Analyzing
Sharm
FEBRUARY 5
Last
seperate
JANUARY 30
End
of tolerance?
JANUARY 24
No
legitimacy
JANUARY 20
Still
talking
about the election
JANUARY 12
Running
for prez
JANUARY 6
Nuke
charges
pop up again
JANUARY 3
Khafre's
turn
DECEMBER 29
His
own money
DECEMBER 23
Fayed
is back
DECEMBER 20
Waking
from
a deep slumber?
DECEMBER 17
"Make
undies,
not war"
DECEMBER 14
Bugging
Baradie
DECEMBER 12
It's
all about peace
DECEMBER 8
A
post-Arafat thaw?
DECEMBER 6
Six
students
for Azzam Azzam?
DECEMBER 2
Big
money
NOVEMBER
2004
OCTOBER
2004
SEPTEMBER
2004
AUGUST 2004
JULY 2004
JUNE 2004
MAY 2004
APRIL 2004
MARCH 2004
FEBRUARY 2004
JANUARY 2004
DECEMBER 2003
MORE
FOR
EGYPT HEADLINES CLICK HERE
Cairolive.com's Egypt headlines section surfs the net for you, searching high and low for the most
useful and interesting stories out there about Egypt. Here you'll find the most discerning links to up-to-date
news and entertainment -- if it's important and
about Egypt on the net, we'll find it for you first every single time.
![](../../small_logo.gif)
Disclaimer
and Terms of Use
© Copyright 1996-2005 cairolive.com. All Rights Reserved
|